Skip to content
Home » News » Affordable housing formula is broken: 28% of New York renters are ‘extremely low-income’

Affordable housing formula is broken: 28% of New York renters are ‘extremely low-income’

  • / Updated:
  • Edwin Viera 

The reality of “affordable” housing is changing in New York, and advocates for renters’ rights argued it is time for an update.

For years, affordable housing has been defined by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development as 30% of a person’s gross income, including utilities. But the combination of higher prices, recent inflation and stagnant wages has been eroding this formula.

Teresa Watson, housing justice organizer for the nonprofit People United for Sustainable Housing in Buffalo, thinks the definition is lacking because it doesn’t account for people with different sources of income.

“When we’re talking about seniors, folks on fixed incomes or people who get SSI, SSI checks come in at about $900 a month,” Watson observed. “That means if you’re paying $300 in rent, which is almost impossible unless you manage to win the Section 8 lottery, you’re still supposed to live off of $600.”

According to the National Low-Income Housing Coalition, 963,000 renter households, or about 28% of renters in New York, are considered extremely low-income. The coalition estimates there is a deficit of more than 615,000 available homes in the state for lower-income renters.

RELATED: Is the housing market cooling off in the Finger Lakes? (video)

Watson believes rather than using catchall solutions, such as low-income housing tax credits for builders, there should be a national reinvestment in public housing, and communities should look for more individualized solutions.

She feels public housing is truly an affordable housing model, but the system needs a serious overhaul.

“The disinvestment has not only made them unsafe and often unsanitary places to live, they haven’t been kept up, they haven’t been invested in,” Watson contended. “They’ve been stigmatized, they’ve been overpoliced. But it is the only housing in our country that actually bases what somebody pays on what they make.”

In particular, Watson pointed out Western New York is seeing an affordability crisis as rents skyrocket. One issue she noted is existing properties are often owned by out-of-town landlords who base rents on what they can get, not on the condition of the property.

Categories: NewsNew York State