Geneva’s city manager says the misconduct case involving three current and former police officers has rattled the community and reinforced the need for accountability in law enforcement.
City Manager Amie Hendrix issued a statement Wednesday, one day after former officer Michael Tapscott, Sgt. David Felice, and William McGowan were arraigned on a range of charges tied to drug-related misconduct and abuse of power. All three were released pending further court action.
“These charges do not reflect the values of the City of Geneva or the many officers who serve with integrity and dedication each day,” Hendrix said. “We are fully cooperating with the ongoing investigations and will continue to ensure that accountability remains central to how we move forward.”
Tapscott faces the most serious charges: 32 counts, including criminal sale and possession of controlled substances, official misconduct, and petit larceny. Felice is charged with tampering with evidence, drug possession, and official misconduct. McGowan faces one count of tampering with physical evidence.
Investigators say the case began with Tapscott’s arrest in May and grew into a months-long probe led by the Ontario County Sheriff’s Office, with help from Seneca and Wayne County officials. They say seized phones revealed over a million text messages, including drug trades and exchanges involving prescription meds, sneakers, and ammunition.
Tapscott is also accused of pocketing a controlled substance while responding to a medical call.
“This situation is serious and affects every one of us,” Hendrix said. She credited Police Chief Ron Eveland for cooperating throughout the investigation and praised officers who “continue to serve this community with professionalism through very difficult circumstances.”
The city said it will keep reviewing internal systems and expectations for employees. “Trust is built through honesty and consistency,” Hendrix said. “We are committed to doing that work every day.”
The case remains active in Ontario County Court.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].