Ten former corrections officers appeared in Oneida County Court this week in connection with the deadly beating of Robert Brooks at Marcy Correctional Facility last December. Prosecutors extended formal plea deals in what has become one of the most closely watched custodial death cases in New York State history.
Brooks, 43, was originally from Monroe County. He died just hours after arriving at the medium-security prison. A state medical examiner ruled the death a homicide caused by neck compression and multiple blunt-force injuries.
Prosecutors Offer Plea Deals as Pretrial Dates Set
During Monday’s pretrial conferences, Judge Robert Bauer heard from each of the defendants. Special prosecutor William Fitzpatrick, the Onondaga County District Attorney, confirmed that his office had sent plea offers to each defendant late last week. However, he declined to share details, citing the active legal proceedings.
Each defendant will return to court in mid to late April to either accept or reject the deals. Here is when they are scheduled to appear:
- Nicholas Anzalone, charged with second-degree murder – April 15
- Nicholas Kieffer, facing murder, manslaughter, and gang assault charges – April 15
- Nicholas Gentile, charged with tampering with evidence – April 15
- Michael Fisher and Michael Mashaw, both charged with manslaughter – April 16
- Mathew Galliher, Anthony Farina, and David Kingsley, all facing murder and manslaughter charges – April 29
- Christopher Walrath and David Walters, both charged with manslaughter – April 30
Fitzpatrick also noted that the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of New York is conducting its own investigation. Federal prosecutors may forgo filing charges if a universal resolution is reached through the state proceedings.
Body Camera Footage Sparks Outrage
Surveillance and passively recorded body camera video reportedly played a crucial role in the indictments. Prosecutors say officers beat Brooks multiple times shortly after his arrival at the prison on December 9, 2024.
Video shows officers carrying him facedown by his limbs, slamming him against a window, punching his torso and face, and choking him. One officer placed both hands around Brooks’ neck and lifted him from an exam table in the infirmary.
The autopsy revealed that Brooks had a broken nose, extensive bruising, and internal bleeding in his neck and groin area. He was later pronounced dead at a nearby hospital.
Family Demands Justice
The Brooks family filed a federal wrongful death lawsuit, alleging that New York’s prison system is “dangerously broken.” Their attorney, Elizabeth Mazur, described the case as “open and shut,” urging the courts to hold those responsible accountable.
Meanwhile, the Correctional Association of New York has flagged systemic abuse at Marcy Correctional in past reports. After interviewing over 100 inmates in 2022, the group described a “pervasive culture of fear and retaliation.” Notably, several of the officers now facing charges were previously named in abuse complaints.
State and Federal Response Intensifies
Governor Kathy Hochul has taken steps in response to the case. She appointed a new superintendent at Marcy Correctional Facility and launched a broader initiative to reform the state’s prison system. Hochul also ordered the termination of all state employees involved in Brooks’ death—some have already resigned.
Additionally, the New York State Correctional Officers and Police Benevolent Association condemned the incident, stating, “We cannot and will not condone this behavior.”
Fitzpatrick emphasized the importance of deliberate legal action. “These are people’s lives we’re talking about,” he said. “We intend to proceed carefully and thoroughly.”
What Comes Next
All ten defendants have pleaded not guilty. If they reject the plea deals, the case will likely proceed to trial later this year. At the same time, the federal investigation remains active, focusing on potential civil rights violations and broader issues within the state’s correctional system.
As the court dates approach, the Brooks family and civil rights advocates remain committed to seeking justice—and pushing for overdue reforms in New York’s prison system.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].