Median home prices across much of the central Finger Lakes continue to rise compared to last year, intensifying affordability challenges even as realtors report a cooling market. New October data shows significant year-over-year price gains in several counties, creating what many buyers describe as a widening gap between “market conditions” and real-world affordability.
This analysis focuses on Cayuga, Seneca, Ontario, Wayne, and Schuyler counties. Yates County was excluded due to unstable data tied to small sample size and seasonal high-end listings.
Ontario and Cayuga lead regional price growth
Ontario County remains one of the region’s most expensive markets, with the median listing price up more than 8 percent year-over-year to $439,000. Cayuga County saw similar movement, posting an increase of more than 10 percent compared to October 2024.
For local buyers, these increases aren’t abstract numbers — they’re the difference between being able to compete and walking away.
“I keep hearing that things are cooling, but nothing in my price range ever actually gets cheaper,” said one Gorham-area buyer who has been searching since spring. “The houses may be sitting longer, but they’re still out of reach.”
Another buyer from Auburn, who spoke with FingerLakes1.com but didn’t want to be identified in this article, put it more bluntly: “Cooling doesn’t help me if the starting price is still fifty or a hundred thousand dollars above what people around here make.”
Seneca and Wayne see declines, but affordability hasn’t improved
Seneca County’s median price dropped nearly 15 percent from last year, but still sits just shy of $285,000 — far above what many local households can reasonably afford. Wayne County, which saw prices slip nearly 9 percent, remains close to $250,000 despite the year-over-year decline.
Buyers say those numbers don’t reflect accessibility.
“When prices fall from impossible to still impossible, that’s not a win,” said a first-time buyer Elise Johns, a Canandaigua resident who has been renting and hoping to buy with her partner for several years. “Realtors keep telling us it’s a better time to buy. I don’t see it.”
Schuyler County’s sharp drop hasn’t translated into opportunity
Schuyler County posted a steep 27 percent decline in median listing price, but the median — $259,900 — remains far above what many residents can afford, especially as interest rates and utility costs remain elevated.
Another renter from Watkins Glen who was hoping to buy said the shift hasn’t made house hunting easier. “I’m still priced out, even after the drop,” Rick Elsworth said. “Everything livable gets scooped up, and everything else needs $100,000 in work.”
Affordability continues to erode
Across the region, the gap between market signals and household reality remains wide. Prices are either rising or holding well above pre-pandemic levels, even in counties showing year-over-year declines. With mortgage rates still reducing buying power, new construction hampered by high utility and infrastructure costs, and inventory returning only gradually, many buyers say the system feels locked against them.
“Everyone keeps telling us the market is normalizing,” a couple living in Auburn told FingerLakes1.com. “But normal for who? Certainly not for the people who live and work here.”
Local housing officials and planners say meaningful affordability gains will require more than a cooling market. Without infrastructure upgrades, new housing investment, and regulatory changes that make construction viable again, price relief is unlikely to reach the average buyer.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].