Concerns about a proposed housing development at Blue Heron Hills Golf Course dominated public comment at the Walworth Town Board meeting this week, with multiple residents urging officials to prioritize transparency and preserve recreational land.
Details of the proposal
A development plan submitted to the Town of Walworth seeks approval to build 47 single-family homes on more than 200 acres at Blue Heron Hills. If approved, the project would cut the golf course in half, reducing it from 18 holes to 9.
The application, prepared by Passero Engineering on behalf of Windward Lake Homes, states the development is intended to expand housing opportunities in Walworth and meet rising demand for suburban living in Wayne County. In a letter of intent, the firm said the project aligns with the town’s long-term goals of promoting responsible growth and increasing housing availability.
Resident opposition keeps growing
Several speakers at the meeting questioned the completeness and clarity of the preliminary site plan. Residents cited inconsistencies in the application, lack of defined development phases, and worries about demolition activity before approvals are finalized.
“This is not the time…to be considering getting rid of a resource that’s been here from the very beginning,” said Woodland Circle resident Lewis Snow. He noted that Blue Heron Hills is one of only four areas in Walworth designated for recreation and said losing it would eliminate 25% of the town’s recreational opportunities.
Nearby homeowner Joe Bruening, whose property borders the course, said he and his wife chose their home because of the golf setting and fear that a community fixture more than 40 years old could vanish. “Nobody’s happy about it,” he said, pointing to dozens of lawn signs on his street that read, “Stop the destruction of Blue Heron Hills Golf Course.”
Town response
Anthony Gonzalez asked whether the plan covered the entire site or if additional phases were expected. Town officials encouraged him and others to attend the Planning Board meeting on Sept. 8, where the proposal will be reviewed publicly for the first time.
Stephanie Fullette, also of Woodland Circle, asked how to submit questions in advance. Board members advised her to email the Building Department, which will forward inquiries to the Planning Board. Officials emphasized that the Town Board does not approve site plans, which fall under the Planning Board’s authority.
“Those initial plans aren’t the be all, end all,” said Councilmember Jenna Camacho, urging residents to follow the process and remain engaged.
Town Supervisor Rick Johnson said he understands the frustration but stressed the review will be lengthy. “It’s not one meeting and they make a decision,” he said. “There’s various studies that have to be done — environmental impact, traffic — and that involves the state, county. It’ll be quite extensive.”
The Planning Board is scheduled to hear the proposal Sept. 8 at 6:30 p.m. at the Town Hall, where Windward Homes is expected to present details of the project.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].