Seneca Falls approved its 2027 budget Tuesday in a 3-2 vote, setting the town property tax rate at $6.09 per $1,000 of assessed value after a dispute over tax calculations, landfill funding and retiree health benefits.
The Nov. 17 decision followed weeks of negotiations and a failed budget vote five days earlier. The approved approach increased direct landfill support to approximately $1.512 million and called for adjusting the general fund withdrawal to maintain the $6.09 rate.
The board also voted 3-2 to add approximately $173,089 for retiree health assistance.
Tax rate becomes the deciding issue
Much of Tuesday’s debate centered on the difference between increasing the property tax levy — the total amount collected through property taxes — and increasing the tax rate applied to assessed property values.
The opening proposal included a $4.72 million levy, described as a 2% increase. During discussion, however, the board heard that the accompanying tax rate would be $6.55 rather than the $6.09 discussed during earlier workshops.
Compared with the prior-year rate of $5.97 cited during the meeting, $6.55 would represent an increase of nearly 10%. The approved $6.09 rate is approximately 2% higher.
For a property assessed at $100,000, a $6.09 rate produces a $609 town tax bill, up $12 from a $5.97 rate, assuming the same taxable assessment.
The successful motion specified the $6.09 rate and directed that the amount drawn from the general fund balance be adjusted to achieve it.
More landfill money and accumulated funds
Supervisor Frank Schmitter opened the meeting with a spending outline totaling approximately $11.03 million. Its financing included $1.25 million in landfill revenue, approximately $1.042 million from the tax stabilization account and approximately $4.017 million from the general fund balance.
The approved approach increased the direct landfill allocation to $1,511,944, approximately $262,000 more than the opening proposal.
Supporters argued that the allocation should reflect 25% of payments already collected during the previous year’s fourth quarter and the current year’s first three quarters. That would base the calculation on receipts rather than estimates of future payments.
Discussion put the revised general fund withdrawal at roughly $4.259 million. The motion left that amount adjustable to maintain the approved tax rate.
The approach renewed the disagreement over how much accumulated money the town should use to support annual spending.
Schmitter argued that tax increases should keep pace with inflation to avoid larger increases later and reduce pressure on the town’s remaining funds.
“We should be looking at 20 years from now, 30 years from now, not tomorrow, not this week,” he said.
Supporters of the lower rate emphasized the financial pressure residents face from utilities and other household expenses.
Retiree assistance wins a separate vote
The board approved approximately $173,089 for retiree health assistance before voting on the revised budget.
Supporters described the provision as replenishing benefit balances, with actual spending dependent on retirees’ use of the money. They argued that retirees on fixed incomes face substantial out-of-pocket medical expenses.
Opponents questioned the size of the provision after discussion indicated that two retirees had exceeded their existing allowances.
The vote addressed an issue left unresolved at the previous meeting, when additional retiree assistance was among the objections raised before the budget failed.
The disagreement continued after Tuesday’s budget vote, with opponents questioning the cost and supporters defending the town’s responsibility to former employees.
Before adjournment, Schmitter confirmed that the revised budget had passed 3-2.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.


