District residents will head to the polls next week to decide whether Williamson Central School District should move forward with a two-part capital improvement plan totaling $22.84 million, a proposal officials say addresses aging infrastructure, safety upgrades, and long-term instructional needs across all three school buildings. The vote will run from 3–9 p.m. at the high school cafeteria.
The plan is divided into two propositions. Proposition 1, the base project, totals $19.29 million and includes roof replacements, aging water-system upgrades, safety improvements, and targeted classroom and instructional-space renovations at the elementary, middle, and high schools. Proposition 2, costing $3.55 million, would relocate the district’s softball and baseball fields to the high school campus and create new synthetic-turf infields, sod outfields, dugouts, scoreboards, walkways, and related features. Proposition 2 may only pass if Proposition 1 is approved.
District leaders say infrastructure needs are urgent
Superintendent Bridget Ashton and district administrators have emphasized that the project is driven by the 2022 Building Conditions Survey and subsequent facilities assessments, which identified extensive infrastructure aging across the district. Needs include deteriorating roofs, outdated or failing piping, aging mechanical systems, worn or outdated classroom features, and safety-related door, alarm, and accessibility improvements.
Financial planners working with the district say state building aid is expected to reimburse roughly 84% of eligible costs. District financial documents state there would be “no impact on the tax levy,” with the plan relying on capital reserves, fund balance, and the district’s existing debt-service profile.
According to the project timeline, state education officials would review plans in 2026, followed by bidding in 2027 and construction between spring 2027 and summer 2028.
Critics question overall spending and long-term strategy
Opposition to the project surfaced during the district’s December 3 public hearing and in emails circulated afterward. Resident Greg Palis argues the district is committing taxpayers to a long series of expensive capital projects despite declining enrollment, noting that administrators have said capital cycles could occur every four years to maintain all buildings. He contends the spending is excessive and calls for closing the district’s middle school—the oldest facility—rather than reinvesting in it.
Palis argues the middle school needs such extensive work that continuing to fund it lacks “common sense,” citing roof replacement, boiler upgrades, plumbing and drainage needs, and structural and accessibility improvements. He says the high school was designed to support far more students than currently enrolled, and that consolidating grades into fewer buildings could reduce long-term capital costs.
Supporters highlight maintenance responsibilities and state reimbursement
District officials have countered that New York requires school buildings to be maintained to state standards and that long-term disinvestment is neither permissible nor cost-effective. They argue that avoiding needed repairs would accelerate deterioration, increase emergency repair expenses, and lead to higher taxpayer costs over time.
Financial documents prepared for the district show that both propositions fall largely within state aid eligibility limits, meaning most project costs would be reimbursed. The district’s modeling shows state aid covering most or all building-related debt service in future years when combined with existing reserves.
Turnout expected to be decisive
Palis has urged property owners to vote, arguing that low turnout could determine the outcome of the referendum. District officials have not responded publicly to his claims but continue to emphasize that the project affects core safety systems, building integrity, and instructional spaces used by students and staff.
Voting will take place Wednesday, December 10, from 3–9 p.m. at the Williamson High School cafeteria.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].