As 2024 comes to a close, we take a look back at the top ten most-read stories that captured the attention of our readers. From environmental concerns and heartfelt rescues to tragic accidents and community resilience, these stories defined the year for the Finger Lakes region.
#1 — Harmful algal blooms wreak havoc on Finger Lakes waters
The devastating spread of harmful algal blooms (HABs) across the Finger Lakes dominated headlines this year. Unseasonably warm temperatures and calm waters accelerated cyanobacteria blooms, forcing closures at popular beaches, including Deep Run Beach on Canandaigua Lake and several swimming areas on Owasco Lake. Despite local leaders spending seven years crafting proposed regulations to reduce agricultural nutrient runoff—believed to be the primary contributor—the state Department of Health rejected these rules, deeming them unnecessary. The rejection sparked frustration among Auburn city officials and environmental advocates, who argued that these outdated regulations put drinking water quality for thousands of residents at risk. [READ MORE]
#2 — Deputy rescues dog in distress, earns heartfelt thanks
In a heartwarming display of compassion, Deputy Steele of the Seneca County Sheriff’s Office rescued Zowie, a dog whose collar had become trapped in the wooden slats of a family porch. The quick response prevented further harm to the panicked animal. The Cahn family, Zowie’s owners, expressed their gratitude in a heartfelt letter and included a donation to the Sheriff’s Office to honor the deputy and the 911 dispatcher who coordinated the rescue. The Sheriff’s Office shared the touching story on social media, where it resonated with thousands of residents. [READ MORE]
#3 — Fire devastates Connie’s Diner in Waterloo
A devastating fire broke out at Connie’s Diner in Waterloo, marking the second major incident at the beloved eatery in just four years. The fire, which originated in the soffit and roof area, caused significant interior damage but was contained by the swift response of fire crews from multiple counties. While the restaurant was closed on the day of the fire, the damage dealt a heavy emotional blow to the community. Support poured in from residents and local businesses, with the restaurant reopening weeks ago. [READ MORE]
#4 — Finger Lakes Drive-In perseveres through legal dispute
This summer, the Fingerlakes Drive-In became the center of a legal standoff with the Cayuga Nation, which blocked the theater’s main entrance with concrete barriers. The dispute stemmed from questions over the validity of the property lease. Undeterred, theater owner Paul Meyer quickly constructed a new entrance nearby, ensuring patrons could still enjoy summer movies at the local landmark. In November, a judge ruled against the Cayuga’s in the dispute. [READ MORE]
#5 — Tragic car crash claims lives of two sisters in Cayuga County
The Finger Lakes region mourned the heartbreaking loss of sisters Hailey and Shelby Trumble in a double-fatal car crash near Ira Hill and Farnam roads. The young women, both recent high school graduates, were celebrated for their vibrant spirits and contributions to their community. A third passenger sustained critical injuries. In response to the tragedy, community vigils were held, and a scholarship fund was established in the sisters’ memory to support local students pursuing higher education. [READ MORE]
#6 — Shooting at Tops in Seneca Falls shocks community
A shooting in the parking lot of Tops grocery store in Seneca Falls left one man critically injured and the community on edge. The victim, Antonio Cavan Ortiz, was airlifted to Upstate Hospital with life-threatening injuries. Police quickly apprehended the suspect, Jose A. Garcia-Vellen, who was charged with first-degree assault. The incident prompted a heightened police presence and renewed conversations about community safety. [READ MORE]
#7 — Pete Mitchell sells iconic Parker’s restaurants
After nearly five decades in the hospitality industry, Pete Mitchell announced the sale of most of his renowned Parker’s Grille and Tap House locations across the Finger Lakes. While he retained ownership of the Newark location, other branches—including the one in Seneca Falls—were transferred to long-time employees and local entrepreneurs committed to preserving the beloved restaurant’s character. The announcement marked the end of an era for a brand synonymous with Finger Lakes dining. [READ MORE]
#8 — Tornado confirmed in Canandaigua
In July, an EF-0 tornado tore through Canandaigua, leaving uprooted trees, snapped utility poles, and hundreds of homes without power. The tornado, which tracked 0.7 miles from the lakeshore, caused significant property damage but fortunately resulted in no injuries. Cleanup and recovery efforts began immediately, with utility crews and volunteers working tirelessly to restore normalcy. The incident served as a stark reminder of nature’s unpredictability. [READ MORE]
#9 — Crosman Corp. announces closure in East Bloomfield
Crosman Corp., a major employer in East Bloomfield since 1971, announced it would cease operations following its acquisition by Daisy Manufacturing Co. The closure left over 140 employees facing layoffs, prompting concerns about economic stability in the region. Local officials have since been actively seeking new tenants for the 50-acre site, hoping to revitalize the local economy and provide new job opportunities for displaced workers. [READ MORE]
#10 — Auburn superintendent predicts school mergers
In an impactful interview, Auburn Superintendent Jeff Pirozzolo highlighted the inevitability of school district mergers across Cayuga County. Declining enrollment, financial pressures, and evolving educational priorities are driving these discussions. Pirozzolo emphasized the potential benefits of specialized high schools tailored to technology, trades, and the arts. While such changes face logistical and cultural challenges, the superintendent argued they are essential for sustaining quality education in the region. [READ MORE]
As we turn the page on 2024, these stories remind us of the strength, compassion, and resilience that define the Finger Lakes community. Here’s to a new year filled with growth, reflection, and hope.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].