Skip to content
Home » News » New York State » Good Cause Eviction remains sticking point in state budget debate among Democrats and Republicans

Good Cause Eviction remains sticking point in state budget debate among Democrats and Republicans

  • / Updated:
  • Staff Report 

The proposed Good Cause Eviction law has ignited a fierce debate between Republicans and Democrats in Albany, promising to directly impact renters across New York. Republicans voiced strong opposition to the bill, which aims to cap rent increases and requires landlords to justify evictions. A compromise that may raise the rent increase limit from three percent to 10 percent is reportedly in discussion. This legislation seeks to protect tenants like Rochester resident Yalitza Galan, who faces eviction despite her long-term tenancy and reliance on rental assistance from Section 8.


Galan’s situation sheds light on the contentious nature of the Good Cause Eviction measure. Facing eviction to make way for higher-paying tenants, Galan and her family are emblematic of the struggles many renters endure. The bill could offer tenants like Galan a legal recourse to contest evictions, requiring landlords to demonstrate a just cause in court. However, Republican leaders argue that the measure could discourage landlords from maintaining or investing in rental properties, potentially leading to a reduction in available housing units and deterring larger businesses from investing in New York.

The debate over Good Cause Eviction is part of a broader discussion on housing and tenant rights. While Democrats point to the successful implementation of similar laws in states like New Jersey, Republicans cite negative impacts in places like St. Paul, Minnesota. The outcome of this legislative battle could reshape New York’s rental market, affecting tenants and landlords alike. With New York’s state budget extension pending and the legislature set to vote, the fate of the Good Cause Eviction measure remains uncertain, leaving tenants like Galan in limbo.