Auburn’s firefighters say the city reduced department staffing before securing approval of a new labor agreement, creating additional overtime expenses when City Council initially rejected the deal.
In a statement following the contract’s eventual approval, Auburn Professional Firefighters IAFF Local 1446 estimated the added expense at $40,000 to $50,000 per pay period. The union defended its staffing concessions and accused city officials of making financial decisions before negotiations were settled.
Council approved the previously rejected agreement Nov. 12 after Mayor Jimmy Giannettino changed his vote. He joined Terry Cuddy and Christina Calarco in the 3-2 majority, while Craig Diego and Rhoda Overstreet-Wilson remained opposed.
The unchanged contract runs retroactively from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2029.
Earlier concessions set the stage
The union said it had already agreed to staffing reductions during the previous contract, allowing the city to leave positions vacant after retirements and transfers. What began as three positions ultimately became four, according to the statement.
Firefighters described reopening that agreement as an unusual concession made to help Auburn address its financial problems. They said the arrangement also established that staffing would not be discussed during the next round of bargaining.
Nevertheless, staffing returned to negotiations. The resulting agreement reduces the contractual workforce from 71 to 65 positions and lowers the minimum number of firefighters per shift from 14 to 12.
The union said it accepted those changes to help control expenses, despite concerns about having fewer personnel available to respond and protect one another.
“Let there be no misunderstanding: We do not consider this a ‘good’ contract,” the statement said.
Smaller workforce, higher shift minimum
The central criticism concerns how the city staffed the department before council approved the agreement.
According to the union, Auburn began operating with the proposed 65-person workforce July 1 while the previous contract still required at least 14 firefighters per shift. When council rejected the deal in September, that higher shift minimum remained in force.
The union says the resulting need to cover shifts generated an additional $40,000 to $50,000 in expenses per pay period. That figure is its estimate, rather than a verified total for the dispute.
It also argued that council members understood the staffing situation before voting against the contract.
“These decisions were detrimental to the City’s financial interests and could have been avoided,” the statement said.
Overtime costs also figured prominently in Giannettino’s explanation for reversing his vote.
In an interview published Nov. 18, he said further analysis showed that maintaining the old staffing requirements during arbitration could cost hundreds of thousands of dollars, potentially reaching into the millions depending on how long the process lasted.
The department lacked enough available employees to meet the 14-person minimum without overtime, he said. Approving the contract allowed that minimum to fall immediately.
His projections addressed potential future expenses during arbitration. The union’s estimate concerns added costs it attributes to the city’s earlier staffing decisions.
Firefighters defend the agreement’s trade-offs
The contract provides 3% annual raises while increasing employees’ share of health insurance premiums to 16.25% in the first year, 17.5% in the second and 18.75% in the third.
It also retains protections against leaving covered positions vacant or abolishing them for economic or budgetary reasons, while allowing hiring to coincide with available recruit training.
Those protections remained a sticking point during the November vote. Diego questioned both affordability and the restrictions on future budget decisions. Overstreet-Wilson asked whether an independent scheduling review could identify alternatives.
The union pushed back against suggestions that firefighters were benefiting at other employees’ or taxpayers’ expense. It said the raises do not offset inflation and higher health insurance contributions, leaving members with less purchasing power.
At the same time, it argued, the smaller workforce saves Auburn money on salaries, pensions and health coverage.
Firefighters said they accepted the agreement because they recognized the city’s financial difficulties, and pledged to continue serving residents despite their disagreements with its leadership.
“Our commitment to the citizens of Auburn has never wavered, and it will not waver moving forward,” the statement said.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.


