Advertisement
Wednesday, November 18, 2026NewslettersAdvertiseWatch FL1
GET LOCALGo ad-freeHigh school sportsLocal eventsObituaries
News

Auburn mayor says overtime risk drove firefighter contract reversal (video)

Auburn Mayor Jimmy Giannettino says projected overtime costs and arbitration risks persuaded him to reverse his vote on the firefighter contract. He also discussed rising insurance expenses, a proposed Byrne Dairy land sale, Bombardier redevelopment and his undecided plans for the 2027 election.

Auburn mayor says overtime risk drove firefighter contract reversal (video)

The prospect of paying months of overtime while a labor dispute went to arbitration persuaded Auburn Mayor Jimmy Giannettino to support the same firefighter contract he rejected in September.

Giannettino said further financial analysis showed that keeping the old agreement’s staffing requirements in place could cost Auburn hundreds of thousands of dollars, potentially reaching into the millions depending on how long arbitration lasted.

The new agreement immediately reduced the minimum number of firefighters on a shift from 14 to 12, giving the city a way to reduce overtime while preserving negotiated staffing protections.

Speaking with Guy Cosentino on Inside Government, the mayor described the decision as a financial tradeoff. His concerns about health insurance costs remained, but pursuing a better agreement carried expenses of its own.

The interview also covered rising city costs, a proposed Byrne Dairy land purchase, redevelopment of the former Bombardier property and Giannettino’s still-unresolved plans for the 2027 election.

Overtime calculations changed the mayor’s position

Giannettino said he asked the comptroller to calculate the cost of continuing under the previous contract while arbitration proceeded.

The department lacked enough available employees to meet the 14-person shift minimum without overtime, he said. Those costs also carried Social Security and pension expenses.

Arbitration could take six to 18 months, Giannettino said, leaving the city exposed to continuing costs throughout that period.

His original objection centered on health insurance contributions. He wanted firefighters to pay 25% of their premiums, but said the potential savings from that change would not outweigh the overtime exposure he was reviewing.

Council approved the unchanged agreement 3-2 on Nov. 12, with Giannettino joining Councilors Terry Cuddy and Christina Calarco. Craig Diego and Rhoda Overstreet-Wilson opposed it.

The contract runs through June 2029, provides 3% annual wage increases and raises employee health insurance contributions in stages to 18.75%. It retains protections against eliminating covered positions for economic or budgetary reasons.

Opponents questioned affordability and the limits those protections place on future budget decisions.

Giannettino said negotiators sought removal of the no-layoff language but could not obtain agreement.

Insurance costs keep pressure on the budget

The mayor said Auburn’s broader health insurance arrangements require changes, although existing contracts limit how quickly the city can act.

“Short answer is no. It’s not sustainable,” he said when asked whether municipalities can continue covering employee insurance costs as they traditionally have.

Auburn is seeking proposals for insurance consulting services and examining alternatives. Giannettino said the firefighter agreement allows the introduction of high-deductible plans as an option, rather than requiring employees to enroll.

The city faces an approximately 22% health insurance increase, along with higher electricity costs. Giannettino said those expenses threaten progress made through the previous budget’s reductions.

City Manager Jennifer Haines has separately warned that departments are already stretched thin while Auburn tries to rebuild reserves.

Guitar Lessons for Christmas

Giannettino said the size of the 2027-28 budget gap has not been calculated. Sales, occupancy and cannabis tax receipts have improved, but the city will again seek additional state assistance.

The $2 million in state support helping the current budget remains a one-time allocation unless more funding is secured, he said.

His larger goal is a permanent change to Aid and Incentives for Municipalities funding.

The state comptroller reports that base AIM funding remains unchanged at $715.2 million statewide in 2026-27, while a separate temporary municipal assistance program increased to $150 million.

Giannettino argued that development grants cannot substitute for dependable operating aid.

“What is the benefit of a DRI if you can’t fund basic services?” he asked.

Byrne Dairy talks follow direct outreach

Giannettino said he initiated discussions with Byrne Dairy by writing to Carl Byrne after seeing the company invest elsewhere in Central New York.

The letter identified available Auburn property, including land at Technology Park and the former Bombardier site.

Council is scheduled to consider a Technology Park land sale Nov. 19. Giannettino said the proposed use would involve manufacturing or operations, rather than a gas station, but declined to disclose details still under discussion.

The bigger picture

Auburn City Council

More reporting on this topic.

Explore this topic →

He said no construction timeline had been established and the land sale had not yet been approved.

At Bombardier, Giannettino sees the private owner’s demolition work as a step toward making the roughly 15-acre industrial property more marketable.

He pointed to rail access, an electrical substation and the $8.5 million Restore New York award associated with redevelopment. He would like to attract manufacturing, potentially connected to Micron’s supply chain.

The city’s demolition schedule anticipates completion by early February 2027. Auburn says the owner is paying the entire demolition cost, with no city or grant funding used for that work.

Giannettino said he is researching companies that might be interested in expanding or relocating and could pursue outreach similar to his Byrne Dairy letter.

Diner relocation remains unresolved; election decision waits

Giannettino said interested parties have examined Hunter’s Diner but have not found a financially workable project.

The city still wants the diner moved. One interested group considered keeping it in place, he said, but the work required proved too costly.

The mayor also defended his participation in the firefighter vote after questions about his uncle’s employment in the department. Giannettino said he had sought legal guidance on previous contracts and had been told the family relationship did not preclude him from voting.

He said he wished he had restated that relationship and guidance publicly before the latest vote.

Asked about running again in 2027, Giannettino said he had not decided. He expects to make that decision sometime after the start of the year, weighing family considerations and increasing responsibilities at MEDENT.

“I just want to make sure that I can continue to give 100% to both of them,” he said.

Want to go ad-free?

Become an FL1 member and say goodbye to ads! Plus, you’ll be supporting a company rooted in the Finger Lakes for nearly 30 years.

$4.99 / month

Get ad-free access

Renews monthly. Cancel anytime through your account. Already contributing via Google? Sign in with your Google account and unlock ad-free access. Embedded YouTube videos and other third-party media players may still contain ads.

Start your day with FingerLakes1

Get the stories that matter from across the Finger Lakes, delivered to your inbox.

Your email will be added to our newsletter mailing list, hosted on Substack. Privacy policy