Small communities in the Finger Lakes face a difficult water-bill calculation: Pipes, pumps and treatment plants keep getting more expensive to maintain, even when customers use less water.
The American Society of Civil Engineers’ 2026 report card for New York’s infrastructure warns that smaller utilities are especially vulnerable because they have fewer customers to share rising operating and replacement costs.
The findings connect directly to discussions already unfolding in Seneca County, where officials have proposed higher water and sewer charges to cover maintenance and operating expenses.
They also reach into the region’s smallest communities. The report names Rushville among examples of small wastewater systems, explaining that limited staffing, technical resources and revenue make maintaining those systems more challenging.
Using less water does not eliminate fixed costs
New York’s infrastructure received an overall C-minus, down from a C in 2022. Drinking water earned a C-minus, wastewater received a D-plus and stormwater received a D.
Those are statewide grades, rather than ratings of individual Finger Lakes communities.
The report describes a financial problem that can be difficult for customers to see. Conservation and efficient appliances reduce water consumption, but utilities still must maintain treatment plants, storage tanks, pumping stations and underground pipes.
When a system relies heavily on charges based on water use, declining consumption can reduce revenue without producing an equivalent reduction in expenses.
The result is that the cost of maintaining the same infrastructure must be recovered from fewer gallons sold.
Smaller utilities face another disadvantage: They often lack enough customers to spread out the cost of major repairs, equipment replacement and new treatment requirements. Limited staff and technical resources can also make it harder to plan improvements before equipment fails.
Seneca County has already confronted the problem
In August, Seneca County’s Public Works Committee advanced proposed water and sewer rate increases after officials described operating costs that existing charges were not adequately covering.
The proposal for Water District No. 1 would have increased the minimum quarterly bill by $32.89.
Water and Sewer Director Daniel Schmalzel told supervisors the district needed to account for maintaining its own pumps, valves, storage tank and other equipment, in addition to paying higher wholesale water costs.
Some expenses had been supported through project accounts, he said, but those funds eventually run out while routine maintenance costs continue.
The county also considered increasing Sewer District No. 1’s per-unit charge from $45 to $57.50. Officials said the district had experienced shortages near the end of recent budget years, driven largely by higher utility costs.
The discussions prompted supervisors to suggest reviewing rates more regularly instead of allowing long gaps followed by larger adjustments.
Repairs and new treatment demands compete for money
The report says New York’s drinking water infrastructure needs exceed $45 billion over 20 years in current dollars.
Utilities must balance replacing aging equipment with addressing contaminants, strengthening resilience and meeting changing regulatory requirements.
In Seneca Falls, officials earlier this year advanced sewer contracts and pursued a proposed $16.5 million water-system improvement.
- Benham Street parking proposals draw competing requests in Penn Yan
- Walworth seeks interim town justice; applications due Dec. 2
- Auburn considers splash pad or smaller pool as Casey Park’s future remains unsettled
- Geneva City Council to weigh e-bike rules, South Main Street changes and short-term rental taxes
The water proposal included treatment equipment to improve PFAS removal, additional pumping capacity and replacement of aging mains. The town also awarded more than $5.2 million in construction contracts for the Kingdom Road sewer project.
The report emphasizes that infrastructure condition and drinking water compliance are different measures. It says 98% of New York water systems reported no maximum contaminant level violations in 2025, even as utilities faced substantial replacement needs.
Engineers call for maintenance funding and more operators
The report recommends predictable funding for construction, operations and maintenance, along with better inventories of equipment and long-term replacement plans.
It also identifies a shortage of trained wastewater operators as a major challenge. Retirements, limited recruitment and increasingly complex treatment technology can strain the workforce responsible for keeping facilities running.
Central New York offers one example of a broader approach to infrastructure improvements. The report highlights Onondaga County’s Save the Rain program for using green infrastructure to reduce combined sewer overflows while providing flood-control and neighborhood benefits.
For smaller communities, the recommendations include expanding operator training and recruitment, strengthening preventive maintenance and securing sustained financial assistance so repairs can be planned before failures force emergency spending.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.


