Proposals to change traffic and parking on Benham Street have drawn competing requests from Penn Yan residents, with some supporting one-way travel, others favoring a parking ban and several urging a compromise that preserves both parking and two-way access.
The village presented two options in an Oct. 13 letter: make Benham Street one-way from Clinton Street toward East Elm Street while retaining parking, or keep two-way traffic and eliminate street parking.
The issue reaches beyond convenience for drivers. Residents have raised concerns about shared driveways, visitor parking, business deliveries, emergency access and traffic on neighboring streets.
Benham Street parking was listed for public comment at the Public Safety Committee’s Nov. 10 meeting, alongside broader parking recommendations, a revised StarShine parade plan and a baseball field advertising agreement.
Residents disagree over access and safety
Village officials raised concerns in August about buses and fire trucks navigating Benham Street. Then-Police Chief Thomas Dunham recommended investigating after Mayor Patricia Christensen received a resident’s complaint.
The subsequent request for neighborhood feedback produced sharply different accounts of how changes would affect daily life.
Adam Benedict, who lives at 116 Benham St., said eliminating parking would create substantial difficulties because his household shares a driveway. Visitors would have to park on Elm or Clinton streets and walk to his home, including during winter.
Aline Trombley supported one-way traffic, saying limited driveway space makes street parking important for households along the block.
John and Connie Kerrick favored retaining two-way traffic and eliminating parking. They said parked vehicles make entering and leaving their driveway difficult.
Greg Griffin, owner of HK Griffin & Son at 119 Benham St., also supported two-way traffic without parking. He said vehicles obstruct access for delivery trucks and his own truck, and asked for consistent enforcement.
Several residents proposed a third approach.
Will and Susan Knepple suggested designated parking sections separated by clear areas where opposing vehicles could pass. They asked the village to consider delivery access, emergency vehicles, horse-and-buggy traffic and effects on surrounding streets. They also suggested a temporary trial before permanent changes.
Robert, Anneke and David Wheeler recommended targeted restrictions near intersections and congested business areas while keeping parking elsewhere.
Review extends to signs and village parking rules
A Nov. 3 memo from Village Attorney Ed Brockman identifies questions about parking signs and their relationship to village code on several other streets.
Brockman said restrictions should be checked against signs on Keuka Street, Burns Terrace, Court Street and Glencoe Drive. He also identified locations on Rosewood and Highland drives where reported no-parking signs lacked corresponding restrictions in the village’s vehicle and traffic chapter.
At the boat launch, Brockman suggested reconsidering how the village regulates overnight parking because fishing activity often occurs during hours of darkness. He also recommended checking accessible parking locations and signs.
The Nov. 10 agenda separately listed one-way traffic on Water Street.
Existing seasonal parking restrictions prohibit parking on village streets from 2 to 6 a.m. between Nov. 1 and April 1. The business district has year-round restrictions during those hours.
StarShine proposal would move parade staging
Another proposal would move staging for the Lights on Wheels parade to the Yates County Fairgrounds to reduce disruption along East Main Street.
StarShine is scheduled for Saturday, Dec. 5, from 3 to 6 p.m., with the parade following at 6:30 p.m.
In a Nov. 9 request, Jessica Bacher proposed having vehicles assemble at the fairgrounds, proceed onto East Main Street and finish at Court Street, with unloading in the Penn Yan Academy parking lot.
- Branchport/Keuka Park seeks Penn Yan fire contract decision by Dec. 1
- Penn Yan board sets Nov. 20 special meeting for audit exit conference
- Penn Yan board to review 5% lodging tax, annexation and parking proposals Tuesday
- Penn Yan officials confront rising costs, aging infrastructure in budget workshop
Bacher said staging along East Main Street blocks residential driveways and requires closing the street while participants line up. The fairgrounds would provide more room and allow a longer parade route.
If weather makes the East Main Street hill unsuitable, the proposed alternate staging area would be between Lake Street and Commercial Avenue.
The event has changed its format before. Organizers combined StarShine and Lights on Wheels into one evening in 2024, citing volunteer demands and the opportunity for visitors to enjoy both events.
The chamber’s current event page lists Main Street activities, shopping, food, entertainment and children’s activities for this year’s celebration.
Baseball advertising and audit meeting also on village calendar
A proposed agreement would lease the Elm Street Sports Complex baseball outfield fence to Penn Yan Youth Baseball and Softball Inc. for $1 during 2027.
The organization could sell advertising space to raise money for baseball equipment purchases and repairs. Alcohol, tobacco, cannabis and vaping advertisements would be prohibited, and annual reporting would account for advertisers, income and expenditures.
The village would retain ownership and maintenance responsibility for the fence.
Trustees also have a special meeting scheduled for Nov. 20 for an audit exit conference with BST Gallagher Flynn and village business as needed. That meeting begins at 11 a.m. in Room 202 of Village Hall, 111 Elm St.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.


