New York buyers have more homes to choose from, but rising prices and slower sales show how difficult the housing market remains. New Cornell research adds another concern for homeowners struggling to keep up: Whether they receive mortgage relief can depend on information their lender does not have.
The statewide median sale price reached $450,000 in September, up 5.9% from a year earlier, according to the New York State Association of Realtors. Available inventory rose 9.8% to 35,294 homes, while completed sales fell 1.4%.
Those figures describe a market where additional listings have yet to bring lower statewide sale prices. Meanwhile, the Cornell study examines a different part of the housing challenge: What happens when a homeowner can no longer comfortably afford the mortgage.
More listings, fewer purchases
New York’s September housing report, released Oct. 20, counted 9,893 completed sales and 9,091 pending sales. Pending transactions declined 5.4% from September 2025.
The supply of available homes increased from 3.6 months to four months. That remained below the six to 6.5 months the association considers a balanced market.
Borrowing costs also increased. The association reported that the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate was 6.86% in September, compared with 6.35% a year earlier.
Across the Finger Lakes, the price of entry varies considerably. August median sale prices ranged from $230,000 in Cayuga County to $403,708 in Tompkins County. Ontario County’s median was $360,000.
Those monthly medians reflect the homes that sold, and small county sales totals can produce substantial swings.
Why mortgage relief can fall short
Lauri Kytömaa, an assistant professor of applied economics and policy at Cornell, studied how lenders decide whether to offer struggling borrowers assistance when processing that assistance costs money and the borrower knows more about their circumstances.
A homeowner might anticipate a job loss or an expensive divorce. Another might have access to family help that would make continued payments possible.
“Institutions didn’t know exactly who needed the aid and who didn’t,” Kytömaa told Cornell Chronicle.
His analysis used approximately 162,000 Fannie Mae-guaranteed mortgages originated in California from 2004 through 2007. Its findings concern historical loans and modeled outcomes, rather than a forecast of New York foreclosures.
The study, published Nov. 9 in The Review of Economic Studies, estimated that incentive payments under the federal Home Affordable Modification Program reduced foreclosures by 3%.
However, information gaps increased modeled foreclosures by 22% compared with a situation in which lenders had complete borrower information. The analysis also found that the amount of relief available under the program was insufficient to prevent 84% of foreclosures.
The findings point to several obstacles working together: Identifying borrowers who could benefit, covering the cost of arranging assistance and providing enough relief to make repayment workable.
Help for New York homeowners
Kytömaa told Cornell that falling property prices can make it harder for distressed borrowers to sell their homes for enough money to repay their loans. He also cautioned that widespread foreclosures during declining markets can deepen lenders’ losses.
New York’s September median sale price was still rising. For homeowners already struggling with payments, though, the immediate issue is whether their household finances allow them to stay.
The New York attorney general’s office advises borrowers to contact their lender or mortgage servicer as soon as they face foreclosure risk. A nonprofit housing counselor may help negotiate a solution or locate legal assistance.
New York’s Homeowner Protection Program connects residents with free housing counseling and legal services at 855-466-3456.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.



