Advertisement
Monday, November 16, 2026NewslettersAdvertiseWatch FL1
GET LOCALGo ad-freeHigh school sportsLocal eventsObituaries
News

Canandaigua firefighters press for more staff as budget hearing puts hiring debate before residents

Canandaigua’s firefighters union is urging residents to seek increased staffing at Monday’s budget hearing, with four positions requested by the fire chief left out of the proposed spending plan. Council must weigh the hiring costs against a budget that already calls for higher property taxes and utility bills.

Canandaigua firefighters press for more staff as budget hearing puts hiring debate before residents

The city of Canandaigua’s firefighters union is urging residents to demand more staffing at tonight’s budget hearing, bringing its safety campaign directly into deliberations over a spending plan that leaves additional firefighter positions unfunded.

Canandaigua Professional Firefighters IAFF Local 2098 is asking supporters to attend the hearing and tell City Council that increased staffing should be a priority in the 2027 budget.

“Don’t let decisions about our workforce and community services happen without you,” the union wrote in its latest appeal.

The City Council meeting begins at 6 p.m. at the Hurley Building, 205 Saltonstall St. A third budget workshop will follow the council meeting.

Four requested positions remain outside the proposed budget

Fire Chief Frank Magnera requested four additional firefighters during the Nov. 9 budget workshop. City Manager John Goodwin estimated their annual cost at approximately $548,000.

Those positions are not included in Goodwin’s recommended budget.

The department’s current staffing provides at least four personnel on duty around the clock, with five available approximately 40% of the time, Goodwin said.

Magnera told council that small crews must divide critical assignments among too few people, including operating the pump, establishing a water supply, advancing hose and searching buildings. He argued that additional staffing would improve safety and allow responsibilities to be divided more effectively.

A separate city option would add three firefighters at an estimated annual cost of $411,000, establishing a minimum of five on duty around the clock.

The city’s staffing cost comparison estimates that option would add 5.04 percentage points to the proposed general fund property tax levy increase, bringing it to 14.38% if the entire hiring cost were covered through property taxes without offsetting revenue or cuts.

Beeman Street fire continues to drive the debate

The union’s campaign intensified after the Oct. 11 fire at 5 Beeman St., where apartments sit above commercial space.

Finger Lakes Partners (Billboard)

Local 2098 said the four-person initial city crew had to handle searches, fire suppression and water supply while important safety assignments went uncovered. The union has argued that the response demonstrated why more firefighters need to be available before neighboring departments arrive.

The city defended the response and its reliance on mutual aid, saying no residents or responders were injured and crews contained the fire to its area of origin. City officials have said staffing decisions must account for community risk, regional resources, operational needs and taxpayers’ costs.

A city-commissioned assessment supports both stronger mutual aid arrangements and phased increases in city staffing. The Center for Public Safety Management recommended ultimately reaching a minimum of seven firefighters on duty, with nine preferred.

At the Oct. 26 council meeting, former Mayor Bob Palumbo and union President Dan Conklin pressed for action. Palumbo argued that two additional firefighters on duty would have made a substantial difference at the Beeman Street fire. Conklin warned that waiting for a future federal hiring grant could delay trained reinforcements until 2029.

The bigger picture

Canandaigua Fire Department

More reporting on this topic.

Explore this topic →

The union subsequently began offering yard signs supporting increased staffing.

Council faces hiring costs alongside higher household bills

The staffing request comes as residents already face higher costs under the recommended budget.

The proposal includes a $23.34 million general fund budget and a 9.34% increase in the general fund property tax levy. A household with a home assessed at $275,800 and minimum water and sewer bills would pay approximately $254 more annually.

The plan would also use about $590,000 in accumulated savings. Goodwin has cautioned that reserves cannot provide a recurring funding source for ongoing expenses.

Monday’s hearing gives residents an opportunity to weigh in before council continues working through additions and reductions.

The workshop calendar lists another session Nov. 23, with additional workshops Nov. 30 and Dec. 7 if needed. Budget adoption is scheduled for Dec. 21.

Residents can attend in person or join through the city’s Zoom meeting. A livestream is also available.

Want to go ad-free?

Become an FL1 member and say goodbye to ads! Plus, you’ll be supporting a company rooted in the Finger Lakes for nearly 30 years.

$4.99 / month

Get ad-free access

Renews monthly. Cancel anytime through your account. Already contributing via Google? Sign in with your Google account and unlock ad-free access. Embedded YouTube videos and other third-party media players may still contain ads.

Start your day with FingerLakes1

Get the stories that matter from across the Finger Lakes, delivered to your inbox.

Your email will be added to our newsletter mailing list, hosted on Substack. Privacy policy