A case that began as a missing person report has now led to the arrest of five individuals in connection with the homicide of Sam Nordquist, New York State Police announced Friday. Authorities say Nordquist was subjected to months of physical and psychological abuse before being killed and his body transported to a remote location in Yates County.
New York State Police Public Information Officer Trooper Lynnea Crane confirmed that the case, initially treated as a missing persons investigation after Nordquist was reported missing on February 9, 2025, has now been classified as a homicide.
“Throughout this investigation, our dedicated team of law enforcement officers and forensic experts have worked tirelessly to gather evidence, follow up on leads, and uncover the truth about Sam’s disappearance,” Crane stated. “Unfortunately, we must now confirm that this case has transitioned from a missing person investigation to a homicide investigation.”
Crane also noted that due to the ongoing nature of the case, certain details cannot yet be made public to protect the integrity of the investigation. However, authorities confirmed that five individuals have been arrested and charged in connection with Nordquist’s death.
Investigation uncovers ‘horrific’ pattern of abuse
Providing further details, Captain Kelly Swift of the Bureau of Criminal Investigation described a deeply disturbing series of events leading up to Nordquist’s death.
“Based on evidence and witness statements, we have determined that Sam endured prolonged physical and psychological abuse at the hands of multiple individuals,” Swift said. “From early December 2024 to February 2025, Sam was subjected to repeated acts of violence and torture in a manner that ultimately led to his death.”
According to police, Nordquist’s body was later transported in an attempt to conceal the crime. His remains were discovered in a field off Payne Road in Benton, Yates County. The discovery was made as a result of the investigation, though officials declined to comment on the specific lead that brought them to that location.
Following an extensive investigation that involved multiple law enforcement agencies, police executed a search warrant at Patty’s Lodge, Room 22, in the town of Hopewell. That search, along with additional forensic evidence, led to the arrest of the following suspects:
- Precious Arzuaga, 38, of Canandaigua
- Jennifer Quijano, 30, of Geneva
- Kyle Sage, 33, of Rochester
- Patrick Goodwin, 30, of Canandaigua
- Emily Motyca, 19, of Lima
All five have been charged with murder in the second degree under the depraved indifference statute. They were arraigned Friday morning and are being held at the Ontario County Jail without bail.
Ontario County District Attorney Jim Ritts did not hold back when describing the nature of the crime.
“As you’ve heard, the facts and circumstances of this crime are beyond depraved,” Ritts said. “No human being should have to endure what Sam endured.”
Investigation remains active at this time
Investigators continue to piece together the full circumstances of the crime. Authorities have not yet disclosed the relationship between Nordquist and the suspects, stating that forensic analysis and additional witness statements are still being reviewed.
“We haven’t ruled anything out,” Swift said when asked about the connection between the victim and the accused. “There is still significant forensic work that needs to be done, including the downloading of phones and electronic devices to establish communications and possible relationships.”
District Attorney Ritts confirmed that the Grand Jury process will move swiftly, with additional hearings expected in the coming days.
“A preliminary hearing has been set, and we anticipate Grand Jury action very quickly,” Ritts said. “We will work tirelessly with our law enforcement partners to ensure these individuals are held fully accountable.”
When asked about potential sentencing, Ritts clarified that a conviction for second-degree murder carries a sentence of 15 years to life in prison.
Community and law enforcement response
New York State Police Major Kevin Sucher praised the swift action of law enforcement agencies involved in the case, as well as the contributions of community members who provided crucial information.
“The dedication and professionalism of our first responders are a testament to our shared commitment to safety and justice,” Sucher said. “We also appreciate the cooperation of our partners in law enforcement, including the Ontario County District Attorney’s Office, Ontario County Sheriff’s Office, and Geneva Police Department.”
While many details remain undisclosed due to the ongoing nature of the investigation, authorities emphasized their commitment to justice for Nordquist and his family.
“This is one of the most horrific crimes I have ever investigated in my 20-year career,” Swift said. “Our thoughts are with Sam’s family during this incredibly difficult time.”
Public urged to come forward with information
Authorities continue to seek any additional information that may assist in the case. Anyone with knowledge of the events leading up to Nordquist’s disappearance and death is urged to contact the New York State Police at (585) 398-4100 or email [email protected].
“We know that this is just the start of a long road to justice,” Ritts added. “We hope the community will continue to support this investigation and help bring closure to Sam’s family.”
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].