The long-standing debate over the Seneca Meadows Landfill dominated the Seneca Falls Town Board meeting on Tuesday, as residents and local business operators voiced growing concerns about its environmental and health impacts. A special meeting has been scheduled for January 21, 2025, at the Seneca Falls Community Center to discuss the landfill’s 2025 permit.
Residents expressed frustration with the persistent odor and potential health risks tied to the landfill’s emissions. Businesses, including Waterloo Container, highlighted operational disruptions caused by the air quality, with some employees reporting nausea and headaches.
Rich Swinehart of Waterloo Container described how landfill odors affect the company’s workforce and threatened its ability to provide a safe working environment. “We’re paying for air testing, and we will present evidence that shows hydrogen sulfide levels exceeding recommendations,” he said, criticizing the town for its failure to prosecute prior complaints.
Similarly, other local business owners raised fears about long-term environmental contamination impacting their products.
The public opposition was overwhelming, with the board receiving 58 letters and emails about the landfill—53 against it. One Seneca Falls resident, who identified themselves as Heather during the meeting, tied the issue to the town’s identity, referencing its connection to the classic film It’s a Wonderful Life. “No one visits expecting the stench of a landfill,” she said, urging the board to reject the expansion. Due to audio quality of the meeting, which was streamed to YouTube, her last name could not be deciphered.
The issue extends beyond inconvenience, though, with residents like Jean Gilroy reporting personal experiences of prolonged odor exposure. Gilroy described a 13-hour period in November during which the landfill’s odor permeated her home, accusing the operators of ignoring complaints when no hotline calls were made.
Several residents called for independent scientific studies to assess the landfill’s environmental impact. Suggestions included collaborating with Cornell University to investigate air quality issues and exploring ways to minimize odor spread, such as installing windbreaks.
The January meeting will include input from the public and stakeholders, with requests to invite state officials and the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) to address the issue comprehensively. Residents and businesses are urging the town board to prioritize public health and environmental safety over financial incentives tied to the landfill’s operations.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].