A proposed agreement to secure land for Yates County’s public safety facility project failed Monday after residents and housing advocates warned that it could block plans for at least 18 homes in a Penn Yan neighborhood.
Seven legislators supported the resolution and six opposed it, but the measure fell short of the eight affirmative votes required for a majority of the full 14-member legislature. Legislator Terry Button was absent.
The proposal would have allowed the county to negotiate a contingent purchase offer or option agreement for property near McKinley Avenue and Sherman Street while investigating whether it could accommodate a public safety facility.
Opponents argued that reserving the property for county studies could undermine a competing housing proposal. Supporters said securing access before spending money on engineering and environmental work was necessary to evaluate a potentially less expensive location.
Habitat’s housing plans change the discussion
Christopher Bailey, vice president of Yates County Habitat for Humanity, told legislators the organization was actively pursuing the property and working with a grant writer, architects and engineers.
The concept calls for at least 18 homes, he said. Habitat had previously made an offer that did not satisfy the owner’s desired payment timeline, but Bailey said the organization’s financial circumstances had since changed.
Habitat representatives said the organization has completed 21 homes in the county, helping families establish stable housing while adding taxable property.
Residents also questioned locating a jail near existing homes, raising concerns about traffic, neighborhood character and the loss of land available for housing.
Jennifer Sullivan, who lives on Lincoln Avenue, said her family chose Penn Yan partly because of its quiet residential setting. She asked legislators to explore alternatives and involve neighboring homeowners earlier.
Several legislators said the testimony affected their position.
Jesse Jayne said he entered the meeting supporting the resolution but changed his mind after hearing how actively Habitat was pursuing the site.
Richard Willson said homeownership allows families to build equity and remain in the community. He said he did not want the county to prevent Habitat from moving forward.
Sarah Purdy, a member of the public safety facility ad hoc committee, said she believed a new facility was needed but could not support an agreement that might obstruct housing.
“We are at a point where the government needs are colliding with the public will,” Purdy said.
Supporters cite aging systems and construction costs
Legislators supporting the agreement said the county still must resolve serious problems at its existing public safety building.
Patrick Killen described limited space for programming, education and counseling, along with difficulties adapting the existing structure to current expectations.
He cited preliminary estimates of slightly more than $71 million to renovate and expand at the current location, approximately $75 million to replace the building there, and approximately $58 million for a new building on a separate site.
The separate-site figure was for the building itself, rather than a final total project budget.
Douglas Paddock said some building systems are so old that replacement parts must be found used or specially fabricated. The county has previously described electrical, security and heating systems as beyond their useful lives.
George Lawson said the committee had reviewed approximately 14 properties, considering acreage, topography, utility access and whether owners were willing to sell.
Village water, sewer and municipal electricity could reduce construction and operating expenses, he said. Keeping the sheriff’s operations and jail together would also avoid maintaining separate facilities.
Lawson acknowledged that he had not understood the extent of Habitat’s work before the public comments. He said the legislature needed to consider whether it would ultimately support a facility at that location before investing in site testing.
Agreement would have reserved an option, not approved construction
The proposed resolution identified property owned by Floyd D. Lane and Dale A. Lane in the Town of Milo, both inside and outside Penn Yan.
It described an approximately 9.493-acre tract and an additional tax parcel.
Subject to county attorney approval, the agreement could have taken the form of a contingent purchase offer or option. The resolution also would have authorized preparation of environmental review documents.
It did not establish a purchase price or authorize construction.
Chairwoman Leslie Church reiterated that the legislature had not decided whether to build a new facility or renovate the existing one. That question has remained open through earlier public debate over the project.
Seven supporters were not enough for passage
Killen, Edward Bronson, Paddock, Nonie Flynn, Lawson, Richard Harper and Church voted for the resolution.
Purdy, Leigh MacKerchar, Daniel Banach, William Holgate, Jayne and Willson voted against it.
The county’s legislative rules require resolutions to receive a majority of the legislature’s full voting strength, rather than simply a majority of those attending.
The failed vote left the contingent agreement and environmental-review authorization unapproved. Paddock said he would strongly oppose spending money testing the property without an agreement protecting its availability.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.

