A former Orleans County investigator running for sheriff is calling for the immediate reinstatement of the Major Felony Crime Task Force, escalating a dispute over whether its shutdown will save taxpayers money or weaken public safety.
Brett Sobieraski, who announced his campaign against Sheriff Christopher Bourke days before the unit was eliminated, accused the sheriff of putting political interests ahead of residents’ safety. Bourke denies the restructuring was politically motivated and says major felony investigations will continue through his office.
District Attorney Susan Howard also opposes the shutdown, warning that losing three experienced investigators could jeopardize ongoing cases.
The county’s tentative 2027 budget proposes replacing the task force, which operated within the district attorney’s office, with a new organizational model under the sheriff. County officials estimate nearly $400,000 in potential savings.
But the controversy extends beyond next year’s spending plan. Orleans Hub reported that the unit was abruptly shut down Nov. 12, and Howard said she received no advance notice.
In a statement posted to his campaign’s Facebook page, Sobieraski credited the task force with keeping fentanyl and illegal guns off local streets and making nearly 50 arrests involving felony-level drug dealing. He argued that eliminating the unit would undermine that work and called for its immediate return.
Sobieraski singled out an investigation involving Andre Robinson as an example of the task force’s effectiveness.
Orleans Hub reported in August 2025 that the task force and partner agencies investigated cocaine and crack cocaine distribution in Albion, Holley and Medina. Authorities said a search involving Robinson’s Hilton residence resulted in the seizure of approximately a quarter-kilogram of cocaine, $900 and a pickup truck.
That investigation involved cooperation with the Orleans County Sheriff’s Office and other agencies, illustrating the partnership model at the center of the current debate.
Bourke maintains that transferring responsibility does not mean abandoning those investigations.
In his Nov. 14 statement, the sheriff said his office would continue pursuing drug trafficking, illegal firearms and violent crime while working with prosecutors. He described the restructuring as an effort to reduce duplication and use taxpayer money responsibly.
He also rejected Howard’s allegation that the decision was retaliation for Sobieraski’s campaign, calling it an accusation without evidence.
Sobieraski, a retired Rochester Police Department sergeant, announced his candidacy Nov. 10, Orleans Hub reported. Howard subsequently linked that announcement to the elimination of the unit.
In a statement published by WROC, Howard said Sobieraski and two colleagues were fired and that he was escorted from the office by security.
The timing is central to the disagreement, but the competing statements do not establish that the campaign caused the shutdown.
Howard told Orleans Hub that the investigators were retired law enforcement officers working with reduced salary and benefits. She questioned how transferring their workload would produce the promised savings and warned that the disruption threatened cases involving recent arrests and investigations approaching arrests.
The financial argument comes amid broader pressure on county spending.
Chief Administrative Officer Jack Welch’s tentative budget announcement describes a $106.1 million spending plan with a $500,000, or 2.48%, increase in the property tax levy, remaining within the state tax cap.
Welch said health insurance costs would rise by one-third to $9.5 million, retirement expenses would increase 4.6%, and federal changes would reduce administrative reimbursements by more than $400,000.
He identified restructuring the task force as one way to control costs while maintaining services and coordination with local, state and federal law enforcement partners.
Welch also cited felony indictments declining from 50 in 2023 to 28 in 2025, Orleans Hub reported. Those figures describe indictments, a different measure from the arrests Sobieraski cited, and do not by themselves establish whether investigative staffing needs have decreased.
Public responses to Bourke’s Facebook statement raised questions about the transition and the officials’ handling of the dispute.
Holly Burke Hoffmeister questioned why investigators were removed before the year ended. Aaron Justin asked why residents had not been involved earlier. Their comments challenged the process rather than independently establishing how the shutdown was authorized.
Denisse Aguayo criticized the public finger-pointing and called for a setting where residents could understand the issues and engage their representatives. John Sunday urged both sides to work together.
The county’s budget process provides an upcoming opportunity for public input. Orleans Hub reported that a hearing is scheduled for 4:30 p.m. Dec. 2 at the County Legislative Chambers, 14016 Route 31 West in Albion, with a budget vote planned afterward.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.





