A vision to transform Canandaigua’s downtown into a more vibrant, pedestrian-friendly space took center stage at Monday’s City Council meeting.
Consultants from Fisher Associates and Urban Strategies presented preliminary design concepts tied to the city’s $10 million Downtown Revitalization Initiative (DRI) grant. The proposed improvements focus on four key areas: Phoenix Street, Coach Street, Central on Main, and the Mill Street farmers market area.
Designers outlined two options for redesigning the Mill Street area. One maintains vehicular traffic while enhancing pedestrian amenities; the other closes the street to create a more expansive, flexible-use public space. Both would prioritize expanded farmers market functions and improved walkability. The concept that closes Mill Street would reduce available parking from 120 to about 100 spaces, a point of concern for some officials and residents.
Phoenix Street would be redesigned to create a curb-less, all-level pedestrian zone ideal for outdoor dining and special events. Coach Street would be converted to a one-way route westbound from Main Street, with added trees, benches, and clearly defined pedestrian pathways. The Central on Main space would be upgraded with improved shade, seating, greenery, and event staging.
Council members and community stakeholders expressed strong support for the conceptual designs while raising concerns about winter usability, parking displacement, and compatibility with the city’s historic character. Several officials voiced enthusiasm for year-round utility, potentially incorporating heated or covered structures. Others, like BID Director Denise Chaapel, urged planners to consider the needs of downtown businesses and residents—particularly regarding parking and noise impacts on nearby homes.
The council took no formal action on the DRI plans, which remain in the conceptual phase. Residents are encouraged to submit feedback via an online survey at canandaiguadri.com before the next Local Planning Committee meeting on July 29.
In addition to the DRI presentation, the council approved several resolutions:
- $78,000 contract with Aventus for replacing skylights at the water treatment plant.
- Water infrastructure supply contract awarded to Core and Main of Rochester.
- Renewed school resource officer (SRO) agreement with the Canandaigua City School District, shifting more cost burden to the district over a three-year term.
- Creation of a Deputy Treasurer position, funded with a $45,000 budget amendment.
- Agreement allowing a commercial encroachment from West Avenue Plaza onto city property.
- Installation of a new historic marker at Kershaw Park.
- Public hearings scheduled for proposed updates to dumpster regulations and a local law clarifying notice of defect requirements.
Lastly, the city manager warned residents of potential odors or sewer-related issues during a sewer relining project happening from June 18–25. Work will focus on Tillotson, Beale, Niagara, Pleasant, and Catherine Streets.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].