When state auditors asked which Moravia school taps had high lead readings in 2021, district officials couldn’t match the results to specific fixtures. The district now has plans that identify which outlets to test, which ones to keep out of use and who has to tell families what the tests found.
The state comptroller’s office said in a follow-up made public Friday that Moravia Central School District had carried out all seven recommendations from its 2025 audit. The review drew on district records, an interview with the facilities director and a July 29 visit to a sample of outlets.
The finding was part of a statewide audit roundup FingerLakes1 covered Friday. The two Moravia reports and the district’s filings with the state show what went wrong, how the district changed its practices and what it reported for each school.
What went wrong with the 2021 tests
Moravia sampled 188 outlets in May 2021. But the facilities director told auditors he couldn’t find the sampling plan or map that matched the lab’s sample numbers to specific fixtures. He said the records had been misplaced when construction forced him to move his office.
In the original audit, issued in June 2025, auditors counted 303 outlets in the areas they examined. The district had sampled 188 and properly secured 17 outdoor hose connections, leaving 98 outlets that weren’t accounted for by either measure. Auditors couldn’t tell which specific fixtures had been sampled or whether any of the 98 had lead above the limit.
Lab results put 33 of the 188 samples above the state’s action level at the time, 15 parts per billion. The facilities director said he had retested affected outlets used for drinking or cooking, but he couldn’t find those results either. Auditors couldn’t verify which fixtures exceeded the threshold, what had been done to address them or whether they were still in use.
The audit also found that the district didn’t contact the local health department directly about the elevated results and posted results on its website roughly three and five weeks after the deadlines. The superintendent said families and staff were notified by email, but the district couldn’t produce a copy. In a June 2025 letter, school board President Neil Stevens agreed with the findings and said the district would develop a more comprehensive plan.
What the state found when it went back
By July 2026, the district had plans that listed the outlets subject to testing, explained which ones were exempt and spelled out how staff would keep those fixtures from being used for drinking or cooking. At 20 locations visited, reviewers checked 62 outlets against those plans. The district had tested 27 and taken corrective action where needed. The other 35 qualified for exemption.
The review found that the selected outlets either tested below the action level or had controls to keep people from drinking from them, including shutoffs, signs and reminders to students and staff. The district also set up procedures to retain records for 10 years and assigned responsibility for collecting samples, handling lab results, fixing problems and notifying families.
Moravia sampled outlets again in November 2025 and received lab results in three batches between December and January. This time, reviewers found records showing the district notified the required parties on time.
What the latest school-by-school results show
In the state’s 2023–25 reporting database, Moravia reported that all 112 tested outlets at Millard Fillmore Elementary School and all 77 at Moravia Junior-Senior High School were at or below 5 parts per billion. Both entries were updated Jan. 13, 2026.
Those district-reported results cover 189 outlets from the latest cycle. The missing records from 2021 mean there’s no reliable way to match the earlier results to those same fixtures. In July, reviewers examined district records and visited a sample of outlets to see how Moravia put its new procedures into practice. It was narrower than a new audit.
New York lowered its school drinking-water action level from 15 to 5 parts per billion after the 2021 tests. When a result goes above the current limit, schools must stop using the outlet for drinking or cooking, provide another source of drinking water free of charge and notify staff and families in writing within 10 business days. Families can find the district’s posted reports on its water test results page.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.


