A proposal to restore Canandaigua’s traditional summer day camp fell short of enough support during the Nov. 16 budget workshop, leaving the program outside the revised spending model as council members debated its cost, who would benefit and whether a broader recreation plan should come first.
Councilmember Teale Fox urged the city to bring the program back for 2027, arguing that families had lost a dependable summer option.
Staff estimated approximately $200,000 to rebuild the program. The scenario discussed would collect about $100,000 in fees and require a $100,000 taxpayer subsidy.
Four council members supported including the proposal in the model, short of the five needed to advance it through the informal straw poll. The budget remains under review.
Fox argues families need a dependable option
Fox initially proposed restoring a parks and recreation staff position to oversee summer programming, then clarified that her goal was bringing back the day camp.
City Manager John Goodwin said doing so would require more than a single employee. The city would need seasonal staff, supplies and materials to rebuild the program.
Staff said the camp previously served approximately 90 children per week. Covering the full estimated cost through fees would require charging about $340 per child per week.
Fox proposed that the city absorb part of the expense so families would not have to cover the entire cost through registration fees.
She said specialized camps and shorter activities could serve some families, while others needed a consistent program where they could drop off and pick up their children throughout the summer.
“I think that core program needs to come back,” Fox said.
The city continues to offer other summer recreation opportunities. Its 2026 recreation brochure listed city-sponsored programming and independent camp options, while noting that the city would not partner with the Salvation Army for day camp that year.
Cost and residency questions divide council
Goodwin said approximately half the former program’s participants lived outside the city, raising questions about how a taxpayer subsidy would be distributed.
Fox suggested giving city residents an earlier registration window or charging different fees based on residency.
Councilmember Gwen Van Laeken said she was open to broader recreation investment but wanted a more developed proposal before supporting the $100,000 subsidy.
She questioned committing that amount to a camp serving roughly 90 children per week when approximately half were not city residents and the city faced substantial financial pressures.
“I need more information,” Van Laeken said.
After the proposal fell short in the straw poll, Fox objected that the decision also prevented further development of the plan. She argued that council was willing to invest in emergency services while declining a service affecting families’ everyday lives.
Assistant City Manager Shawna Bonshak said work on a redesigned recreation proposal would continue. The approach she described would be developed for a potential 2028 rollout, rather than restoring the traditional camp for 2027.
Fireworks raise a separate recreation question
Council also discussed restoring fireworks at the lakefront, although no agreement was reached on a location or funding package.
Councilmember J.T. Squires advocated bringing the display back to Kershaw Park.
Goodwin said a lake-based display would require approximately $75,000 in capital spending for floats, plus the cost of the fireworks.
Van Laeken proposed setting aside $15,000 for fireworks while reducing the city’s contribution to the Canandaigua Local Development Corporation from $25,000 to $10,000. That would offset the operating expense, but would not pay for the floats needed for a lakefront display.
The town already had plans for fireworks at Outhouse Park, creating questions about coordination and scheduling. Goodwin said returning a display to the lake on July 4 would require working with the town and an available fireworks provider.
Lyon said city and town leadership could discuss the issue further.
Recreation facilities also need investment
The programming debate unfolded alongside concerns about the condition of city recreation facilities.
Goodwin identified problems at the Sonnenberg and Baker park buildings, limitations on providing heated restrooms at Kershaw Park and an unpaved city-owned parking area near the lake.
Squires also sought public restrooms at the city pier.
Goodwin said potential excess reserves could help fund one-time capital improvements once year-end finances are clearer. That would require another decision about priorities, separate from the recurring expense of staffing and operating a summer program.
Council is scheduled to continue its budget review Nov. 23, with adoption planned for Dec. 21.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.


