Canandaigua’s budget problems extend well beyond the additional firefighters and other positions under consideration for 2027, with city officials warning that rising operating expenses, aging facilities and future garbage disposal costs could put substantially more pressure on taxpayers.
During the Nov. 16 budget workshop, City Manager John Goodwin presented projections showing the property-tax levy could more than double by 2032 if the city covered the widening gap between expenses and other revenues entirely through property taxes.
The figures were planning scenarios, not proposed tax increases for those future years. Goodwin said annual budget reviews have reduced earlier projections, but finding enough savings is becoming harder.
Council also approved a sewer-rate increase that will add $44 annually for customers paying the minimum bill. A separate proposed water-rate increase would add another $24.
Expenses are growing faster than revenue
The city’s original 2027 budget proposal called for a 9.34% increase in the general fund property-tax levy.
By the end of the Nov. 16 workshop, a revised model incorporating two additional firefighters, police investigative staffing and a public works asset manager showed a 15.93% levy increase. Those changes remain under consideration.
Goodwin’s longer-term presentation illustrated a broader problem that exists even without those additions.
Under the assumptions discussed, revenues other than property taxes would grow approximately 1% annually overall, while expenses would increase roughly 8% to 8.75%. The model assumed 3% annual sales-tax growth, but that would not be enough to offset increases elsewhere.
Healthcare and retirement expenses were projected to rise at a double-digit pace.
Goodwin said the city reviews spending closely each year, but property taxes remain its principal tool for covering the difference when other revenues cannot keep up.
Councilmember Doug Merrill questioned what those projections would mean for homeowners. Goodwin acknowledged that an individual city tax bill could roughly double under the scenario discussed, while emphasizing that the projections would change as budgets are developed.
Garbage and recycling could add another major expense
The workshop also exposed a cost that had not been included in the initial long-term model: more expensive waste disposal following the anticipated Ontario County landfill closure at the end of 2028.
Goodwin said the city currently pays approximately $45 per ton to dispose of garbage and collects about 2,500 tons annually.
The city currently pays no tipping fee for recycling at the materials recovery facility, he said. A future market-rate arrangement could cost approximately $100 per ton for the roughly 500 tons it collects each year.
Disposal arrangements, transportation costs and potential partnerships remain unresolved. Goodwin identified High Acres and Seneca Meadows as possible destinations for garbage, rather than selected facilities.
He estimated the additional annual expense at $200,000 to $300,000.
Councilmember Gwen Van Laeken asked that the projections account for those costs instead of leaving a foreseeable increase outside the model. Goodwin added a $300,000 annual assumption beginning in 2029.
Sewer increase is approved; water increase remains proposed
Council approved the sewer-rate law following a public hearing that drew no speakers.
Beginning Jan. 1, the minimum quarterly sewer charge will rise from $82 to $93, an increase of $11 per quarter or $44 annually.
The usage rate will increase from $7.322 to $8.3057 per 1,000 gallons, according to the legislation considered by council.
The proposed water increase would add $24 annually for minimum-bill customers if adopted.
Those utility charges are separate from city property taxes. The 15.93% figure discussed at the workshop refers to the total property-tax levy, not the combined increase in taxes, water and sewer bills.
Building repairs create another funding decision
Council members also pressed Goodwin about capital needs that are not fully reflected in the operating-budget discussion.
Police-station electrical improvements and a replacement generator had been pushed to 2028 because they could not fit into the proposed 2027 capital plan. A roof replacement and parking-lot work were already included.
Goodwin recommended waiting until approximately March, when the city has a clearer picture of its year-end finances, before committing potential excess reserves to additional projects.
He said money above the city’s reserve target could help pay for one-time improvements. Council members requested more information about the cost and priority of those repairs as budget deliberations continue.
The next workshop is scheduled for Nov. 23. Budget adoption is planned for Dec. 21.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.


