Geneva residents challenged proposed changes to City Hall’s chain of command Tuesday, warning that shifting comptroller oversight to City Council could complicate daily operations and make recruiting a permanent city manager more difficult.
The Nov. 17 public hearings came as Mayor Jim Cecere announced a seven-person search committee with a goal of bringing a city manager selection before council in February 2027.
Council didn’t adopt the charter amendments Tuesday. Speakers questioned both the need for the changes and how the proposed reporting arrangement would work.
Proposal would change financial oversight
The proposed comptroller amendment would give council appointment and removal authority and establish direct reporting to council on the city’s financial condition.
The city manager would participate in selecting the comptroller. Budget disputes between the two officials would first go to the mayor for facilitation, then could go to council if unresolved after 10 business days.
A separate amendment would add chief administrative officer and principal adviser to the mayor and council to the manager’s designation. The manager is already designated chief executive officer; the proposal would retain that designation and leave the position’s 14 enumerated duties unchanged.
The proposed charter changes are part of Cecere’s broader effort to revise government reporting and advisory structures.
Resident Charles King argued that direct council oversight could leave the comptroller facing conflicting priorities from elected officials and the manager. He questioned whether council would have the expertise to evaluate the comptroller’s performance and warned that the arrangement could undermine the manager’s effectiveness.
Martha Davis questioned what problem the changes would solve. She said elected boards generally handle policy while professional staff manage daily operations, and she worried that blurring those roles would create complications.
Former comptroller warns about workload
Former City Comptroller Ed George, who retired in 2014 after more than 35 years with the city, supported transferring comptroller appointment authority to council.
He said that arrangement could make it easier for the comptroller to speak independently. But he warned about the demands of answering to eight councilors, the mayor and the city manager while also handling department needs, budgeting and state and federal requirements.
George said council already has authority to demand better reporting from the manager and hold that person accountable.
Before opening the hearings, Cecere said disagreements over the proposals should not be interpreted as a loss of confidence in Acting City Manager Taylor Youngs.
“My confidence in her is solid and sound,” he said.
Cecere said he welcomed Youngs’ advice and public feedback as council considers the changes.
Search committee targets February selection
Cecere announced that he would serve on the manager search committee with Councilors Peter Gillotte and John Brennan; Public Works Director Joseph Venuti; Pastor Brian Whitley, also a Geneva school board member; Chevy DeVaney, Hobart and William Smith Colleges’ vice president for diversity, equity and inclusion; and Geneva resident David Strickland.
Human resources staff will provide nonvoting support with applications, procedures and job descriptions.
The committee will review applicants and recommend finalists. Council will interview finalists and make the appointment.
Cecere said the smaller committee should help the search move efficiently while bringing community and operational perspectives into the process.
Councilor Christopher Lavin urged a clear deadline, saying slow searches had previously cost the city strong candidates.
The mayor identified February 2027 as the target for council’s final decision.
Advisory committee structure needs more work
Cecere deferred a fuller discussion of proposed advisory committees, saying he wanted to prepare a more developed framework for a working session.
The contemplated committees concern housing, finance, boards and commissions, and economic development.
He said their structure could be outlined through a governance workbook rather than requiring another charter change. Details about how the committees would operate will return for further discussion.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.


