Residential customers of investor-owned electric utilities would get a $100 bill credit after a utility fails to meet state performance standards under a proposal from U.S. Rep. Josh Riley. The annual credit would rise to $200 in the second year and $300 in the third if the utility continued to fall short.
Riley introduced the Utility Accountability Act on Oct. 13, and the bill was referred to the House Energy and Commerce Committee. In a Nov. 17 announcement, his office pointed to missed customer service targets at NYSEG, Central Hudson and National Grid as a reason for the proposal.
How households would get credits
The bill would require state regulators that already audit investor-owned electric utilities annually to certify the results to the U.S. energy secretary each year. The requirement would apply to utilities whose rates those regulators set. The bill’s definition of state performance standards includes electric reliability and safety standards.
When a state certifies that a utility fell short, the energy secretary would order the regulator to direct the company to credit each residential customer’s bill beginning the following year. The amount would increase by $100 each year until the utility meets state standards.
Utilities would have to charge their investors for the credits. The energy secretary could withhold grants, loans, loan guarantees or technical assistance from a state regulator until it complies with an order.
New York utilities missed customer service targets
The New York State Public Service Commission announced $50.1 million in penalties in July for missed 2025 customer service targets. About $35 million of that amount came from penalties reported for NYSEG, Central Hudson Gas & Electric and Niagara Mohawk, which does business as National Grid.
NYSEG missed its customer satisfaction target, triggering a penalty of about $13.3 million after a second consecutive miss on that measure. Central Hudson faced about $4.7 million in penalties after missing targets for customer satisfaction, complaints and call answering. Niagara Mohawk faced about $17 million after missing two customer satisfaction targets and its call-answering target.
Under existing state rate plans, the penalties reduce shareholder earnings. Depending on the plan, the amounts can be credited to customers automatically or deferred until the next rate case. When the commission announced the penalties, it said requests from NYSEG and Rochester Gas & Electric to waive their customer satisfaction penalties were pending.
Riley’s office said NYSEG, Central Hudson and National Grid had fallen short of minimum customer service standards for four straight years. His office also said more than 5,000 residents of New York’s 19th Congressional District responded to a utility survey. Among respondents, 38% reported unexpected bill increases, 16% reported poor customer service and 7% reported smart meter problems. About two-thirds of those who reported a problem said their utility never resolved it.
Riley has also intervened in NYSEG and Central Hudson rate cases and pursued separate bills on utility costs and practices. One would restrict executive bonuses when rates rise faster than inflation. Another would restrict utilities’ ability to sell data collected by smart meters.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.


