Advertisement
Tuesday, November 17, 2026NewslettersAdvertiseWatch FL1
GET LOCALGo ad-freeHigh school sportsLocal eventsObituaries
News

Hochul moves ahead with school tax credits as critics press for public-school protections

New York has opened applications for a federal education tax-credit program despite objections from teachers unions and public-school advocates over accountability and funding. A new Senate bill would give the Board of Regents control over the state’s participation beginning in 2028.

Hochul moves ahead with school tax credits as critics press for public-school protections

New York is moving ahead with a federal education tax-credit program over objections from teachers unions and public-school advocates, while new legislation would give the Board of Regents control over the state’s future participation.

Gov. Kathy Hochul opened applications for scholarship-granting organizations Nov. 16, setting a Dec. 31 deadline for charities seeking approval for the 2027 tax year.

Her administration says the program can help public- and private-school students without drawing from state or local school budgets. Critics argue that assurance leaves larger questions unanswered about federal tax revenue, private-school accountability and the consequences for public schools if enrollment shifts.

Why critics call it a voucher program

The program gives donors a federal tax credit for contributions to approved charities, which then award scholarships for eligible education expenses, including private-school tuition.

Opponents describe that arrangement as a tax-credit voucher system because it uses a federal tax benefit to help finance private education.

New York State United Teachers President Melinda Person warned Oct. 1 that federal regulations would limit New York’s ability to impose additional standards on participating organizations, schools and expenses. She also raised concerns about supporting private schools with admissions practices that would be unacceptable in public schools.

“New York puts its name on the program, but Washington writes the rules,” Person said.

The objections predate the application opening. In an Oct. 8 statement released by NYSUT, Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins and Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie urged Hochul to reject participation.

Stewart-Cousins argued the federal rules would leave New York without meaningful control over where money goes. Heastie said taxpayer support should prioritize public schools that serve all children and answer to the public.

Hochul’s administration says the Division of the Budget will vet scholarship organizations and conduct continuing oversight to prevent waste, fraud and abuse.

Education leaders want investment in the schools serving all students

The opposition extends beyond teachers unions.

The New York State Educational Conference Board, a coalition representing school boards, superintendents, administrators, parents and other education groups, called for New York to reject the program in its January funding recommendations.

The coalition argued that scholarships would largely subsidize private education while failing to address the underlying challenges facing public schools.

Its broader agenda called for updating Foundation Aid, the state’s main public-school operating aid formula, to better reflect current costs and student needs. Recommendations included accounting for expanded mental health responsibilities, revising regional cost measures and strengthening support for students with additional needs.

For rural communities, access and enrollment are central concerns.

DiSanto Propane (Billboard)

NYSUT’s October statement cited an August letter from Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli warning that underserved and rural students could be left behind, while enrollment losses could put pressure on public-school funding and state and local budgets.

Those are warnings about potential consequences, rather than announced reductions in school aid. Hochul says the scholarship program does not divert money from New York’s public schools or state and local budgets.

A new bill would put the Regents in charge

Sen. John Liu, D-Queens, introduced legislation Nov. 9 that would make the Board of Regents the sole state authority responsible for deciding whether New York participates and which scholarship organizations qualify.

The bill would also prohibit the state tax commissioner from implementing participation without the Regents’ approval.

The proposal remains in the Senate Rules Committee. Its provisions would apply beginning with the 2028 tax year, so it would not change the current application process for 2027.

Supporters of the scholarship program have pushed back.

Dennis Poust, executive director of the New York State Catholic Conference, criticized Liu’s proposal Nov. 10. He argued that working families could use scholarships for tutoring, after-school programs, special education services and technology, as well as nonpublic-school tuition.

The bigger picture

Education Crisis

More reporting on this topic.

Explore this topic →

Poust also said New Yorkers could still claim the federal credit by donating to organizations in participating states if New York opted out.

What families and donors should know

The application opening is for charities seeking state approval to award scholarships. It is not an application for families to receive a $1,700 payment.

Beginning Jan. 1, 2027, qualifying donors may claim a federal credit of up to $1,700 for eligible cash contributions. Married couples filing jointly may qualify for up to $3,400 combined, according to the Internal Revenue Service.

The credit is nonrefundable, meaning it can reduce federal income tax liability but does not create an additional refund beyond that liability. The donor’s credit limit does not establish a family’s scholarship amount.

According to the governor’s announcement, scholarships may cover tutoring, special education services, technology, extended-day and after-school programs, and tuition.

Students qualify under an income threshold tied to their community: Prior-year household income must be no more than three times the area median gross income.

Participating charities must meet federal requirements, including directing at least 90% of annual program income toward qualified educational expenses and providing scholarships to at least 10 eligible students attending more than one school.

Organizations seeking approval for 2027 can apply through New York’s scholarship tax-credit portal through Dec. 31.

Want to go ad-free?

Become an FL1 member and say goodbye to ads! Plus, you’ll be supporting a company rooted in the Finger Lakes for nearly 30 years.

$4.99 / month

Get ad-free access

Renews monthly. Cancel anytime through your account. Already contributing via Google? Sign in with your Google account and unlock ad-free access. Embedded YouTube videos and other third-party media players may still contain ads.

Start your day with FingerLakes1

Get the stories that matter from across the Finger Lakes, delivered to your inbox.

Your email will be added to our newsletter mailing list, hosted on Substack. Privacy policy