Canandaigua City Council moved toward adding two firefighters Monday as a revised 2027 budget model put the proposed property-tax levy increase at 15.93%, up from the 9.34% increase in the city manager’s original proposal.
The revised package also includes police investigative staffing and a public works asset manager. Council indicated support for including those positions during a budget workshop following a public hearing dominated by appeals for more firefighters.
The staffing changes remain proposals. Council used an informal straw poll to guide further budget calculations, with final adoption scheduled for Dec. 21.
Two additional firefighters would cost approximately $274,000 annually, including salary and benefits, City Manager John Goodwin said.
Two firefighters gain support after residents press council
The preliminary agreement followed weeks of pressure over fire department staffing, including concerns about the department’s initial response to the Oct. 11 Beeman Street apartment fire.
Residents, former Mayor Bob Palumbo and firefighters union President Dan Conklin urged council to provide more personnel rather than rely on neighboring departments to fill gaps.
Conklin renewed his support for Chief Frank Magnera’s request for four additional firefighters. He said small increases in the number available on a shift could make a substantial difference in completing critical assignments.
Palumbo challenged the city’s account of staffing growth, arguing that recent additions must be considered alongside positions eliminated years earlier. He also questioned whether firefighters had adequate backup during dangerous interior operations.
Mayor Thomas Lyon tested support for three additional firefighters near the end of the workshop, saying that option would move the department toward five personnel on duty around the clock. He said he was the only supporter.
The proposal for two attracted enough support to remain in the revised model.
During the previous budget workshop, Goodwin said the department’s staffing provides at least four personnel on duty at all times, with five available approximately 40% of the time.
Council questions mutual aid and response demands
Council’s discussion went beyond the number of positions.
Councilmember Gwen Van Laeken questioned whether neighboring departments are automatically dispatched when a structure fire is reported or whether assistance depends on a request from city firefighters.
Magnera explained that the department evaluates the information available and requests additional resources when a working fire is identified. That can happen while crews are traveling to the scene if dispatchers receive additional calls or other confirmation.
He said the city has established response assignments for neighboring departments and that he has advocated for more consistent mutual aid procedures across Ontario County.
Councilmember Doug Merrill also questioned a public comment suggesting that half the department’s calls involve fires.
Magnera distinguished actual fires from broader fire-related responses, including alarms, smoke investigations and gas complaints. He said those calls still require personnel to investigate and determine whether a dangerous condition exists.
Merrill raised regional funding as another possible avenue, pointing to assistance city firefighters provide outside Canandaigua. Magnera said broader regional arrangements would require cooperation from the county and neighboring fire organizations.
Police and public works positions also enter the revised budget
The two firefighters account for part of the increase from the original budget proposal.
Council also supported modeling approximately $153,000 for additional police staffing and $117,000 for a public works asset manager.
Police Chief Mathew Nielsen previously explained that an additional officer would allow an experienced patrol officer to become a detective without reducing patrol coverage.
- Canandaigua firefighters press for more staff as budget hearing puts hiring debate before residents
- Firefighters share frontline perspective in battling intense Crystal Beach blaze (video)
- Canandaigua City Council rejects firefighter additions, opts for safety study instead (video)
- ‘PROPER STAFFING IS CRITICAL’: Canandaigua firefighters respond to three water emergencies in 12 hours
The asset manager would help oversee preventive maintenance, track city facilities and equipment, and plan replacements.
Goodwin clarified that savings from other public works staffing changes were already included in his recommended budget. Adding the asset manager would therefore require the full additional cost.
Council also supported removing a proposed 4% increase in council salaries, saving approximately $2,200.
The resulting 15.93% figure describes the increase in the total property-tax levy. Individual homeowners’ bills would also depend on their assessments and the final tax rate.
Hiring grants remain part of the discussion
Council requested additional projections showing how a federal Staffing for Adequate Fire and Emergency Response grant could support further firefighter hiring.
The proposed budget retains money for grant-writing assistance. Council discussed models involving three or six additional grant-supported positions beyond the two under consideration for 2027.
Magnera cautioned that applying, receiving an award, hiring through civil service and completing training could mean new firefighters would not be fully prepared until late 2028 under the timeline discussed.
“We should be moving forward with at least a couple for next year,” he said.
Councilmember Donna Cator supported hiring two firefighters while pursuing a grant for additional positions. Merrill also urged council to consider other recommendations in the city’s public safety assessment alongside staffing.
Staff will prepare revised figures for further review. The next budget workshop is scheduled for Nov. 23, with budget adoption planned for Dec. 21.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.


