A proposal to change how New York taxes vaping products has divided public health advocates and convenience store representatives, with both sides arguing their approach would better keep illegal products away from young people.
The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids is urging Gov. Kathy Hochul to veto the legislation. Supporters say distributor licensing and stronger enforcement would help officials trace illegal flavored vapes through the supply chain.
The measure, sponsored by Assemblywoman Michaelle Solages and state Sen. Leroy Comrie, passed both legislative chambers June 4. It would change the tax structure and impose new requirements on businesses supplying vapor products to stores.
What would change at the checkout counter?
New York currently imposes a 20% supplemental tax on retail sales of vapor products, in addition to applicable sales tax. Retailers collect the supplemental tax from customers.
The version that passed, A4619B/S4527B, would replace that structure with two rates:
- 32 cents per milliliter for products prefilled and sealed by the manufacturer that are not intended to be refilled.
- 8% of wholesale price for other vapor products.
Distributors would collect the tax from vapor product dealers.
The difference between retail and wholesale taxation matters because the tax would apply to a different price.
For example, under the current system, a product with a $20 retail price carries a $4 supplemental tax. For a product covered by the proposed 8% rate, a $10 wholesale price would generate an 80-cent tax.
Those hypothetical figures illustrate the calculation. They do not establish what a particular product would cost customers after the change.
Why advocates want a veto
The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids’ veto campaign argues that the legislation would reduce taxes on e-cigarettes that appeal to children.
Kevin O’Flaherty, the organization’s associate vice president for state and local policy, told Spectrum News that the group supports moving collection to distributors but objects to reducing the tax burden and questions whether the enforcement provisions would work as intended.
He urged a veto followed by revised legislation through the upcoming state budget process.
Comrie told Spectrum that he was working with the governor’s office on changes to address concerns about the tax structure. He described the legislation’s purpose as improving tracking without placing the responsibility entirely on small businesses.
New York Association of Convenience Stores President Alison Ritchie also defended the proposal in a statement to Spectrum, arguing that it would help authorities identify and pursue distributors supplying illegal products.
Distributors would face new requirements
The legislation would require vapor product distributors to obtain licenses, file monthly tax returns and maintain records subject to inspection.
Retailers purchasing directly from manufacturers or out-of-state distributors would also need distributor licenses.
The proposal would create a state directory of vapor products permitted for sale and provide penalties for selling products outside that system. It also includes restrictions on distributing and storing flavored products.
Those provisions would affect the suppliers behind convenience stores and vape shops across the Finger Lakes, as well as businesses that bring products into New York themselves.
Existing age and flavor restrictions remain important
New York already prohibits selling tobacco and vapor products to anyone under 21. State law also restricts flavored nicotine vapor products other than tobacco flavor, according to the Department of Health.
Changing where a tax is collected would not make underage sales legal.
The sponsors’ stated goal is to strengthen enforcement at the manufacturer and distributor level. Public health opponents contend that enforcement changes should preserve the price deterrent created by existing taxes.
The bill specifies that it would take effect immediately upon becoming law. Businesses should continue following current Tax Department requirements unless a change is enacted and implementation guidance is issued.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.



