Landfill odors, lakefront development, and long-awaited infrastructure projects dominated discussion during the Seneca Falls Town Board’s June meeting, where residents pressed officials on several quality-of-life concerns while the board approved a series of resolutions affecting everything from sewer improvements to downtown beautification efforts.
The nearly two-hour meeting featured extensive public comment, particularly on issues tied to Seneca Meadows Landfill and future development along Cayuga Lake, before the board moved through a lengthy agenda of capital projects, staffing decisions, and community initiatives.
Landfill concerns dominate public comment
The evening began with multiple residents and business representatives voicing frustration about landfill-related issues.
Jean Gilroy criticized the proposed expansion of Seneca Meadows Landfill and raised concerns about plans involving the former Tantillo landfill site. She questioned whether the town should continue promoting tourism, recreation, and youth athletic events while residents continue to experience landfill odors and potential environmental impacts. Gilroy argued that residents should continue participating in public comment opportunities and reporting odor complaints to regulators.
The strongest criticism came from Waterloo Container representative Mark Pitifer, who described a May 15 incident in which employees encountered strong landfill odors inside the company’s facility. According to Petittifer, workers experienced eye and throat irritation, difficulty breathing, and other symptoms that prompted some employees to leave production lines. He told the board that Waterloo Container purchased its own air-monitoring equipment and recorded elevated hydrogen sulfide readings inside the building. Petittifer also accused town officials of failing to adequately respond to complaints and questioned the town’s ability to oversee any future landfill expansion if it could not effectively address current odor issues.
Pitifer submitted 24 employee supporting depositions along with monitoring data and landfill odor reports to the town attorney, arguing that both town and state regulations prohibit odors that interfere with residents’ and businesses’ enjoyment of property.
A representative of Seneca Meadows responded during the meeting, disputing portions of Waterloo Container’s account. The representative said the landfill investigated the complaint, found no detectable odor or gas readings at the time, and encouraged continued communication with landfill staff whenever concerns arise.
Other residents echoed concerns about odors, with one speaker noting that landfill smells are noticeable well beyond Seneca Falls and can be detected while returning from Rochester.
Residents raise concerns about lakefront development and dog safety
Another major topic involved ongoing development along Lower Lake Road.
Resident Ann Wilkes expressed concern about a recently constructed lakefront property that she believes is being developed as a multi-unit short-term rental despite being presented as a single-family residence. Wilkes argued that the project is out of character with the neighborhood, could worsen parking problems, impact views of Cayuga Lake, and encourage similar development along the shoreline. She urged the town to strengthen zoning regulations before additional projects move forward.
Town Attorney David Foster responded that the town’s planning committee is already working on proposed zoning changes for lakefront properties. He said officials expect to present amendments to local zoning regulations in the coming months and noted that the town already maintains a permitting process for short-term rentals that addresses issues such as parking, garbage collection, and local contacts.
The board also heard from resident Martha Utica, who recounted being seriously injured in a dog attack nearly three years ago. She urged officials to strengthen local regulations governing dog restraints, arguing that aging tie-outs and insufficient setbacks from sidewalks create dangerous situations for pedestrians and children. Utica said she continues to encounter unleashed or poorly restrained dogs throughout the community and fears another serious incident could occur if regulations are not updated.
Sewer project moves forward despite rising costs
One of the most significant actions taken by the board involved the long-discussed Kingdom Road sewer project.
Board members approved a resolution scheduling a public hearing for July 7 on increasing the project’s financing after construction bids came in substantially higher than earlier estimates. According to Foster, the project was previously authorized at approximately $5.5 million, but bids now require the town to increase financing authority to roughly $6.5 million. Town officials said rebidding the project was unlikely to generate significant savings because construction costs continue to rise and the town remains within the time period needed to hold contractors to their submitted bids.
The public hearing will be required before the town can adopt a revised bond resolution and move forward with construction.
Bridge lighting project enters environmental review
The board also took the first formal step toward adding decorative lighting to the It’s a Wonderful Life Bridge as part of the Downtown Revitalization Initiative.
Rather than completing environmental review immediately, officials approved a resolution declaring the town’s intent to serve as lead agency under the State Environmental Quality Review Act. Foster explained that the action begins the environmental review process and allows notices to be distributed to other involved agencies before final approvals are considered. Board members discussed the possibility of installing programmable lighting capable of displaying different colors for holidays and special events.
Community projects, staffing and events approved
The board approved several additional resolutions during the meeting.
Among them were appointments to the Historic Preservation Commission, authorization for a New York State historic marker at the Partridge Building on Fall Street, funding for Convention Days programming, authorization to seek grant administration services for the Kids Territory park project, installation of a bulk water distribution point at the highway department, and corrections to police retirement enrollment records for Lieutenant Thomas Cleere and Sgt. Bethany Kidd.
Board members also approved the hiring of a part-time zoning officer and debated how to fill a vacant building maintenance mechanic position. While some officials argued the position should remain full-time due to the technical skills required and ongoing maintenance needs, the board ultimately chose to move forward by advertising for a part-time position first.
The board additionally approved permits for several upcoming events, including a Community Foam Party at Academy Square, a Seneca Falls Historical Society cemetery tour, and the Cycling the Erie bicycle tour, which is expected to bring approximately 550 cyclists and visitors to Seneca Falls in July.
Supervisor announces lung cancer study presentation
During his monthly report, Supervisor Frank Schmitter announced that a representative from the New York State Department of Health will present findings from a regional lung cancer study during a public meeting July 9 at the Seneca Falls Recreation Center.
Schmitter also encouraged residents to volunteer for a newly formed stormwater and wastewater compliance committee that will focus on reducing stormwater infiltration into the town’s sanitary sewer system, a problem that contributes to flooding and sewer backups during major rain events.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to news@fingerlakes1.com.
