Veterans urged Ontario County supervisors Thursday to adopt a full property tax exemption for qualifying disabled veterans, telling the board that rising assessments and living costs are making it harder for some former service members to remain in their homes.
However, the board didn’t vote on the exemption. Chairman Bill Wellman said he hoped to move the issue through committees and bring it onto the board’s agenda within roughly a month.
“This is actually not on the agenda tonight, but I would hope in the next month or so it’ll be on our agenda,” Wellman said after the speakers finished.
He said officials were working to correct information they had received about the program and expressed optimism about moving the proposal forward.
Veterans ask county to act
Chris Edgerton, a retired Air Force veteran who said he served for 25 years, including five years deployed, asked supervisors to lead an effort that could extend to towns and school districts throughout Ontario County.
Edgerton said veterans with permanent service-connected disabilities should receive support reflecting the sacrifices they made. He urged the county to adopt the exemption and encourage other taxing jurisdictions to follow.
Jonathan Prater described the pressure that rising property assessments can place on veterans living on fixed benefits.
“My home did not suddenly become twice as affordable simply because its value increased on paper,” Prater said.
He criticized the pace of consideration and said veterans need financial relief that helps them stay in homes they worked to purchase and maintain.
Paul Newhook, a Town of Canandaigua resident and veteran, acknowledged the board’s responsibility to consider the effect on other taxpayers. He urged supervisors to determine how many homeowners would qualify and evaluate the cost using that narrower population.
Speakers offered different estimates of the number of potentially eligible veterans. The meeting did not establish a verified count of qualifying homeowners or an official county estimate of the exemption’s financial effect.
Eligibility requires permanent and total disability
The exemption is a local option under state law. Counties, cities, towns, villages and school districts can choose whether to offer it for their respective taxes.
Current state eligibility guidance says qualifying veterans must have documentation from the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs specifically establishing that they are permanently and totally disabled because of military service. They must also meet the applicable alternative veterans exemption requirements.
The benefit applies to a qualifying veteran’s primary residence. A 100% disability rating alone does not establish eligibility for the permanent and total disability exemption.
County adoption would address county taxes. Separate decisions by municipalities and school districts would determine whether the exemption applies to those portions of a homeowner’s bill.
Ontario County Board of Supervisors
More reporting on this topic.
Explore this topic →- Ontario County seeks food-waste input at Nov. 17 workshop
- Ontario County supervisors seek room tax changes, approve labor deal and delay Lake Ontario resolution
- Ontario County advances $24 million FLCC culinary center, adopts animal abuser registry
- Ontario County delays vote on Seneca landfill expansion
Victor Town Board member Alexis Ogra urged supervisors to support the new exemption alongside any consideration of expanding existing senior or veterans benefits.
She said the county could maintain its overall levy while changing how that levy is distributed among taxable properties. Her comments addressed the debate over how much relief qualifying veterans would receive and how the remaining tax burden would be shared.
Chairman anticipates committee review
David Poteet, a Canandaigua resident who described years of work with veterans at the VA, asked supervisors to consider the circumstances of people living with lasting injuries and limited income.
He urged the board to weigh the potential benefit to individual veterans alongside the county’s financial considerations.
Wellman thanked the speakers and said their information would help the county’s review. He described the next step as committee consideration before a proposal comes before the full board, without announcing a specific vote date.
For homeowners, receiving the benefit also requires an application once their taxing jurisdiction offers it. The state Tax Department directs veterans to their municipal assessor to confirm availability, documentation requirements and the local filing deadline.
Make FL1 part of your day.
Local reporting. Useful updates. More ways to stay close to your community.
Go ad-free
Support independent local reporting and enjoy FL1 without display ads.
$4.99 / month
Become a member →Cancel anytime. Third-party media players may contain ads.Get the daily briefing
Start your morning with the headlines that matter across the Finger Lakes.
Find more FL1 on Google
Choose FingerLakes1.com as a preferred source to see more of our reporting in your Google news results.

