Advertisement
Monday, November 16, 2026NewslettersAdvertiseWatch FL1
GET LOCALGo ad-freeHigh school sportsLocal eventsObituaries
Sports

Brett Gardner joins 2027 Hall of Fame ballot; Pettitte, Rodriguez and Abreu return

Brett Gardner joins the 2027 Hall of Fame ballot alongside returning candidates Andy Pettitte, Alex Rodriguez and Bobby Abreu. Voting closes Dec. 31, with results scheduled for Jan. 19.

Brett Gardner joins 2027 Hall of Fame ballot; Pettitte, Rodriguez and Abreu return

Brett Gardner is on the National Baseball Hall of Fame ballot for the first time, bringing renewed attention to a 14-season Yankees career marked by speed, defense and influence in the clubhouse.

The former outfielder is a candidate for the 2027 class after playing his entire major league career in New York from 2008 through 2021. In MLB’s account of his career, Bryan Hoch described Gardner’s election chances as slim while detailing the impact teammates say he made beyond his statistics.

Finger Lakes Partners (Billboard)

Pettitte, Rodriguez and Abreu return to the ballot

Gardner is among 14 newcomers on the 27-player Baseball Writers’ Association of America ballot unveiled Monday, according to MLB’s full ballot report. Andy Pettitte, Alex Rodriguez and Bobby Abreu are among the 13 returning candidates.

Pettitte received 48.5% of the vote in 2026, an increase of 20.6 percentage points. The five-time World Series champion enters his ninth year of eligibility, leaving two voting cycles to reach the 75% required for election before exhausting the 10-year limit.

Rodriguez returns for his sixth year after receiving 40.0% support. Abreu enters his eighth year after receiving 30.8%.

Chase Utley leads the holdovers at 59.1%, making him the only returning candidate who received at least half the vote in 2026. His support rose 19.3 percentage points in that election, and he now enters his fourth year.

Félix Hernández made the largest gain on the last ballot, rising from 20.6% in his debut to 46.1% in his second year. Cole Hamels received 23.8%, the highest share among the 2026 newcomers.

Posey and Lester join the first-time candidates

Buster Posey joins the ballot after a 12-year Giants career that included three World Series championships, seven All-Star selections and five Silver Slugger awards. He won National League Rookie of the Year in 2010, NL MVP in 2012 and a Gold Glove in 2016.

Posey, Gardner, Ryan Zimmerman and Kyle Seager are the four candidates who spent their entire major league careers with one franchise. Zimmerman played for Washington and Seager for Seattle.

Jon Lester also debuts after 16 seasons, 200 victories, five All-Star selections and three World Series titles. MLB’s report compared his record with fellow left-hander Hamels: Hamels finished with a 123 ERA+ and 57.9 Baseball-Reference wins above replacement, compared with Lester’s 117 ERA+ and 43.5 WAR, in nearly the same number of innings.

The other first-time candidates are Jake Arrieta, Jay Bruce, Asdrúbal Cabrera, Starlin Castro, Wade Davis, Andrew Miller, Pablo Sandoval, Ervin Santana and Joakim Soria. The newcomers last appeared in the majors in 2021.

The remaining returning candidates, with their 2026 vote shares and 2027 ballot years, are Jimmy Rollins, 25.4%, sixth year; Dustin Pedroia, 20.7%, third; Mark Buehrle, 20.0%, seventh; Omar Vizquel, 18.4%, 10th; David Wright, 14.8%, fourth; Francisco Rodríguez, 11.8%, fifth; and Torii Hunter, 8.7%, seventh. Vizquel is in his final year of eligibility.

A championship, speed and a memorable postseason battle

Gardner finished with a .256 batting average, 1,470 hits, 139 home runs and 274 stolen bases. He earned an All-Star selection in 2015 and a Gold Glove in 2016, and his career was worth 44.3 wins above replacement by Baseball-Reference’s measure.

Only Derek Jeter, with 358 stolen bases, and Rickey Henderson, with 326, rank ahead of Gardner on the Yankees’ career list. Gardner also helped New York win the 2009 World Series.

His path began as a walk-on at the College of Charleston. The Yankees selected him in the third round of the 2005 draft, and he reached the majors three years later.

One of his signature postseason contributions came against Cleveland in 2017. Gardner worked through a 12-pitch confrontation with closer Cody Allen before delivering a two-run single in the ninth inning, helping New York advance to the American League Championship Series.

Judge remembers a mentor and demanding teammate

Gardner’s support for Aaron Judge extended beyond the ballpark. Early in 2017, when Judge was staying in a Times Square hotel, Gardner offered him a place at his home in Armonk, N.Y., hoping a quieter setting would help the young outfielder concentrate on baseball.

Judge recalled that Gardner welcomed him, treated him with respect and established expectations for everyone in the clubhouse. He described Gardner as a professional, leader and practical joker.

“I think every team in baseball could use a Brett Gardner,” Allen said after their postseason matchup.

The humor could be elaborate. Hoch recounted pranks involving mustard in protein smoothies, chili peppers added to meals and interference with a staff member’s Chevrolet Suburban battery. Gardner’s intensity also became part of his public identity: his bat-banging response to an ejection in 2019 inspired the Let Brett Bang movement.

The bigger picture

Aaron Judge

More reporting on this topic.

Explore this topic →

CC Sabathia regarded Gardner as central to the team’s character. General manager Brian Cashman credited him with setting an expectation that every detail mattered and every opportunity deserved a fight.

A quiet ending to his playing career

Gardner wanted to finish with the Yankees. After their final playoff game in 2021, he remained in his dirt-stained uniform while reflecting on the uncertainty of getting another chance to wear it.

Hoch reported that Gardner declined a reported $6 million offer from Toronto that winter. The Yankees made no offer, and he never played another major league game.

Gardner has not responded to invitations to the Yankees’ Old-Timers’ Day celebrations, according to Hoch. When New York honored its 2009 championship team in 2024, Sabathia spoke about Gardner’s importance to that group and his hope that Gardner would return.

In March 2025, Gardner’s 14-year-old son, Miller, died during a family vacation in Costa Rica. The Yankees offered support to the family.

Judge continues to acknowledge Gardner at Yankee Stadium by using his former teammate’s bent-knee, flexed-biceps gesture during the nightly Roll Call.

Voting closes Dec. 31

BBWAA ballots are due Dec. 31. Results will be announced Jan. 19, 2027, at 6 p.m. Eastern on MLB Network. Candidates receiving at least 75% of the vote will be inducted July 25 in Cooperstown.

The writers have elected multiple players in each of the past three years, including Carlos Beltrán and Andruw Jones for the Class of 2026. Across the past 10 classes, 11 players have been elected on their first ballot, including Adrian Beltré, Joe Mauer, CC Sabathia and Ichiro Suzuki in 2024 and 2025.

Want to go ad-free?

Become an FL1 member and say goodbye to ads! Plus, you’ll be supporting a company rooted in the Finger Lakes for nearly 30 years.

$4.99 / month

Get ad-free access

Renews monthly. Cancel anytime through your account. Already contributing via Google? Sign in with your Google account and unlock ad-free access. Embedded YouTube videos and other third-party media players may still contain ads.

Start your day with FingerLakes1

Get the stories that matter from across the Finger Lakes, delivered to your inbox.

Your email will be added to our newsletter mailing list, hosted on Substack. Privacy policy