The Cleveland Browns may have just found the future face of their franchise — and a long-awaited solution at quarterback — in Shedeur Sanders.
In one of the most surprising developments of the 2025 NFL Draft, Sanders slid all the way to the fifth round before the Browns aggressively traded up to select him with the 144th overall pick. Once projected as a potential first-round talent, Sanders’ draft-day fall gave Cleveland the rare opportunity to acquire a quarterback with star potential at an extreme discount.
The Browns, who spent significant time with Sanders during the pre-draft process, including a high-profile dinner in Boulder with Sanders and teammate Travis Hunter, clearly see something special. And despite the circuitous route, Shedeur Sanders’ arrival couldn’t come at a better time for a franchise desperate for a new beginning under center.
A Quarterback Room in Transition
Sanders joins a Browns quarterback group undergoing a full-scale reboot. With Deshaun Watson facing a lengthy recovery from a second Achilles injury — and the team publicly acknowledging the $230 million trade as a “big swing-and-miss” — the Browns are preparing for life after Watson.
Alongside Sanders are newly drafted Dillon Gabriel from Oregon, seasoned veteran Joe Flacco, and former Steelers starter Kenny Pickett. Coach Kevin Stefanski has made it clear that the Browns’ quarterback competition will be wide open, offering Sanders an immediate opportunity to rise.
While Flacco provides experience and Pickett brings pedigree, Sanders offers something different: a dynamic mix of toughness, accuracy, and leadership that the Browns have lacked since their brief success with Baker Mayfield.
Why Sanders Fell — and Why It Won’t Matter in Cleveland
Concerns about Sanders’ pre-draft interviews and the fear of “distractions” may have contributed to his unexpected slide. But within NFL circles, many evaluators graded Sanders as a Day 2 or even late-first-round talent.
Ultimately, the slide had more to do with draft logistics — teams filling needs elsewhere — than with Sanders’ ability. Browns general manager Andrew Berry recognized the rare value and acted decisively, saying the choice was about “maximizing value at the game’s most important position.”
In Cleveland, Sanders enters an ideal situation: a team rebuilding its offensive scheme under new coordinator Tommy Rees and desperate for a fresh leader. There’s no entrenched starter blocking his path, and Sanders’ skill set fits Stefanski’s system perfectly.
A Perfect Fit for Stefanski’s Offense
Sanders’ playing style aligns seamlessly with what Stefanski has historically sought in quarterbacks.
He thrives on play action, excels at quick decision-making, and can pick defenses apart with precision short-to-intermediate passes. His poise under pressure, ability to throw off-platform, and knack for holding safeties with his eyes make him a strong fit for an offense designed around timing and rhythm.
Despite some tendencies in 2024 to hold the ball too long at Colorado — a symptom of trying to carry his team — Sanders showed elite flashes that, when placed in a better supporting system, could unlock his full potential.
Sanders’ mental toughness stands out most. He’s not afraid to take hits, keeps his eyes downfield, and consistently delivers in critical moments. In a rugged AFC North, that resiliency could be the difference between heartbreak and playoff victories.
The Stakes Are High — and Sanders Could Be the Answer
For Stefanski and Berry, solving the quarterback position is paramount to securing their future in Cleveland. After eight different starting quarterbacks since 2020 and a 3-14 collapse last season, owner Jimmy Haslam has demanded competitiveness in 2025, even while preaching patience.
With Sanders, the Browns may have finally found a quarterback capable of meeting the moment — and the expectations.
He may not have gone in the first round, but history has shown time and again that greatness isn’t determined on draft night. With the right support, Shedeur Sanders has everything he needs to lead the Browns back to relevance — and to win football games in Cleveland.
This content is brought to you by the FingerLakes1.com Team. Support our mission by visiting www.patreon.com/fl1 or learn how you send us your local content here.