With 11 lakes in the Finger Lakes region, it can be tough to choose where to start. Two of the most popular—Canandaigua Lake and Seneca Lake—offer very different experiences. Here’s how they compare for wine, outdoor recreation, and travel convenience.
Wine and Tasting Room Experience
Seneca Lake is home to the largest and most established wine trail in the region, with over 30 wineries surrounding the lake. From Riesling and Gewürztraminer to Cabernet Franc, the variety and volume are unmatched.
Canandaigua Lake has a smaller but growing wine scene. Wineries like Heron Hill and Arbor Hill offer curated experiences and scenic tastings, but fewer stops overall.
Winner: Seneca Lake for wine trail variety; Canandaigua Lake for boutique tastings.
Scenic Beauty and Lake Access
Canandaigua Lake offers a postcard-worthy setting with a walkable downtown and public lake access at Kershaw Park. It’s ideal for visitors looking for a balance of nature and amenities.
Seneca Lake is larger and more rugged, with deep blue water and vineyard-lined hills. Watkins Glen and Geneva provide good access, but the shoreline is more spaced out.
Winner: Canandaigua Lake for ease of access; Seneca Lake for dramatic vistas.
Outdoor Activities
Seneca Lake has more hiking and natural attractions, including Watkins Glen State Park and Finger Lakes National Forest. It’s also popular for fishing and boat tours.
Canandaigua Lake is known for paddle sports, sailing, and Roseland Waterpark in the summer. The Ontario County Park at Gannett Hill offers sweeping valley views just a short drive away.
Winner: Seneca Lake for hiking; Canandaigua Lake for family-friendly activities.
Travel and Lodging
Canandaigua is closer to Rochester and offers upscale hotels, historic inns, and modern rentals—great for short weekend trips.
Seneca Lake is more central in the Finger Lakes and ideal for longer stays with options in Geneva, Watkins Glen, and rural B&Bs.
Winner: Canandaigua Lake for accessibility; Seneca Lake for extended getaways.
Final Verdict
If it’s your first time in the Finger Lakes and wine is your main focus, start with Seneca Lake. If you’re looking for a relaxing, well-rounded trip with charming downtowns and lakefront access, Canandaigua Lake is a strong choice.
Whichever you pick, spring is the perfect time to visit—before summer crowds arrive and just as wildflowers and vineyards come back to life.
This content is brought to you by the FingerLakes1.com Team. Support our mission by visiting www.patreon.com/fl1 or learn how you send us your local content here.