The Canandaigua Planning Commission approved six applications during its regular meeting on April 9, including signage updates, historic alterations, and special use permits for two new carry-out restaurants. The meeting was held in the Hurley Conference Room at 205 Saltonstall Street and streamed live online.
Wall Sign Approved for Alice’s Red Rose Boutique
By a 5–1 vote, the commission approved a historic alteration for a wall sign at 183 South Main Street for Alice’s Red Rose Boutique (Application #25-038), which had been tabled from the March meeting. Owner Elizabeth Burdick explained the proposed sign would be installed in three separate panels to increase visibility and align with downtown continuity standards. Several commissioners expressed concerns about the size and layout, but the application was ultimately approved as submitted.
Sign Replacement at Adelina’s Approved
The commission unanimously approved signage replacement at 395 South Main Street for Adelina’s (Application #25-044). Owner Carl Simtack noted the new sign matched the size and specifications of the prior sign used by Faro’s Pizzeria. Commissioners acknowledged the sign was already installed due to a miscommunication but found it consistent with prior signage and appropriate for the location.
Historic Window Replacement on Gibson Street
Diane Johnston received unanimous approval (6–0) for a historic alteration to replace three deteriorating kitchen windows on the west side of her home at 60 Gibson Street (Application #25-045). Commissioners discussed the visibility, design consistency, and historical significance of the windows. It was noted that the windows were minimally visible from the street and replacements would mimic the existing pane structure.
Public Hearings Held for Two New Carry-Out Restaurants
Two public hearings were conducted and closed with no opposition for proposed carry-out restaurants:
— Ardor Park Artisanal Pizza (Application #25-051), located at 123 South Main Street, was approved unanimously for a special use permit, signage, and a historic alteration to add an exterior ventilation pipe on the Phoenix Street façade. Owner Cody Durhack stated the operation would primarily serve wood-fired pizza with seating for about 20 and included plans for painted venting and future exterior improvements. Downtown Business Improvement District representative Denise Chaapel spoke in favor of the project.
— Kershaw Koffee (Application #25-052), at 58 Lakeshore Drive, was approved unanimously for a special use permit to operate a coffee shop. Applicant Alex Bacon said the space would include indoor seating for 15–20, offer locally roasted coffee and baked goods, and operate primarily in the mornings. The business will share access with an adjacent gym and plans to open late May.
Historic Driveway Alteration Approved
The final application reviewed, #25-069, requested by Eric Wendorff at 164 North Main Street, was unanimously approved for a historic alteration to pave an existing gravel driveway and add a small turnaround pad behind the home. Wendorff stated the update would improve safety and usability for his family. Commissioners discussed historic considerations and found the project consistent with neighboring properties and not impactful to the character of the district.
Next Meeting
The commission adjourned following discussion and a brief training session. No additional decisions were made. The next scheduled meeting was not announced during the session.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].