Why Are So Many Americans Still Living Paycheck to Paycheck?
Despite holding stable jobs or earning six-figure salaries, millions of Americans remain “cash poor”—without enough liquid cash to cover unplanned expenses. The 2025 SoLo Cash Poor Report reveals a troubling rise in the use of short-term, high-fee financial products, which experts say are making it harder for vulnerable individuals to stay afloat.
With emergency expenses averaging $1,825 in 2024, many turn to subprime credit cards, payday loans, and buy now pay later (BNPL) plans. But the cost of these options is soaring, and the long-term impact can be devastating.
What Are ‘Bad Financial Products’ and Why Are They So Costly?
The SoLo report defines “bad financial products” as short-term, high-interest borrowing tools that often come with hidden or excessive fees. These include:
| Loan Type | Avg. Cost (2024) | Max Cost | Key Drivers of Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Subprime Credit Cards | 48% | 90% | Monthly fees, penalties, high APR |
| Payday Loans | 35% | 67% | Origination & late fees |
| Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) | 2% | 45% | Interest, missed payment fees |
| Earned Wage Access (EWA) | 13% | 26% | Tips, transaction fees |
| Bank Small-Dollar Loans | 25% | 35% | Account/deposit requirements |
| Peer-to-Peer Loans | 17% | 25% | Late fees, platform tips |
| Friends & Family Loans | 0% | N/A | No formal fees but not always accessible |
Real Stories: When Financial Lifelines Become Debt Traps
Ilaria D’Anca of Arizona had once enjoyed a strong financial footing with an 806 credit score and $150,000 in savings. But a series of setbacks, from flooding to legal battles, left her turning to emergency loans.
One loan for a $2,200 truck repair came with a clause that shot the interest rate to 169% if not repaid in three months. “Most Americans would take the bad loan over being stuck in a parking lot indefinitely,” she said.
Why Earned Wage Access Is a Double-Edged Sword
For some, services like EarnIn offer a manageable way to cover gaps between paychecks. Single mom Tenisha James credits EWA for helping her escape late fees and stabilize her finances. However, new regulations in Connecticut are now limiting access to these services.
“They restricted the one thing that finally helped me,” James said. She’s launched a petition to fight the rules and keep EWA legal in her state.
Who Are the ‘Cash Poor’ in 2025?
Being “cash poor” is no longer limited to low-income Americans. The SoLo survey found:
- 1 in 7 cash-poor Americans earn over $75,000/year
- 54% are women
- Two-thirds are Millennials or Gen X
- 40% work full-time jobs
- 14% identify as Black
These figures challenge stereotypes and highlight how systemic financial pressures are eroding stability across demographics.
How to Avoid High-Cost Loans
If you’re facing an emergency expense, consider these lower-risk options:
- Use credit unions for lower interest rates
- Explore EWA platforms with transparent fee structures
- Borrow from friends or family when possible
- Negotiate payment plans with service providers before resorting to loans
Conclusion: The Hidden Cost of Being Cash Poor in America
High-fee financial products are turning short-term setbacks into long-term financial traps. As living costs rise and regulations vary by state, Americans must navigate an increasingly complex and costly financial landscape. If you’re among the cash-poor majority, understanding your options—and the risks—can make all the difference.
Stay informed and protect your finances. Watch for regulatory updates, compare loan terms carefully, and seek out affordable alternatives before turning to high-interest credit products.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].