The New York State Democratic Party says it filed a complaint Wednesday asking election officials to withhold further public matching funds from Republican gubernatorial candidate Bruce Blakeman’s campaign while its contribution claims are reviewed. The request is not a finding that the campaign received improper payments or that the state has suspended any funds.
Party Chair Jay Jacobs sent the Oct. 7 complaint to the state Public Campaign Finance Board and the Division of Election Law Enforcement. He asked for a contribution-by-contribution review of pending claims, a re-examination of payments already made and an immediate audit. The party also wants enforcement officials to investigate the campaign’s disclosure filings.
The complaint follows a Sept. 29 New York Focus analysis that FingerLakes1.com previously reported. That analysis found the campaign had requested more than $860,000 in potential public matches tied to over 2,600 contributions that appeared ineligible. The figure describes money sought, not money the board is known to have paid on those contributions.
What the complaint asks officials to review
Jacobs’ letter cites more than 1,900 contributions from outside New York and more than 500 contributions from New York donors whose total giving exceeded the program’s $1,050 matching threshold. It also points to a Newsday report identifying more than $460,000 in possible duplicate contribution entries in the campaign’s latest disclosure report. Those are findings or concerns cited by the party, not determinations by the elections board.
The letter asks the finance board to reject ineligible or duplicate claims, issue written reasons for nonpayment, and recover any public funds found to have been paid in excess of what the campaign qualified to receive. It asks the enforcement division to examine whether the filings warrant penalties, but does not establish that any violation occurred.
Under the public financing program’s rules for statewide candidates, only eligible contributions from New York residents can generate a match. The eligible contribution must be at least $5, and the state matches up to the first $250 at a 6-to-1 rate. Contributions from a donor whose aggregate giving exceeds $1,050 cannot be matched, according to the Public Campaign Finance Board.
Campaign disputes reporting errors
The Blakeman campaign previously told New York Focus it had corrected errors through amended reports. New York Focus said its review of amended filings still found ineligible match requests. The Democratic Party’s complaint says the latest filings require independent verification rather than relying on further amendments.
The complaint also says Blakeman’s campaign attributed possible duplicate entries in its newer report to the state filing system and promised another amended report, citing Newsday. Jacobs cites the campaign’s reported spending of nearly $10.5 million from July through September and a reported balance of about $178,000 at the end of September. He argues that payments made shortly before the election could be difficult to recover after campaign funds are spent. That is the party’s assessment, not a conclusion by the board.
Blakeman’s campaign had reported receiving nearly $2 million in public matching funds as of July, according to FingerLakes1.com’s earlier coverage. That total does not show whether any of the disputed claims were approved. State election officials told New York Focus that bipartisan staff review claims before payment and that the board can seek repayment if a claim is later found ineligible.
The complaint was public on the party’s website Wednesday. The source material did not include a response from the Blakeman campaign to this specific complaint or a statement from the finance board that it had received the filing or acted on the request.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to news@fingerlakes1.com.
