Finger Lakes families are paying more than ever for groceries, and U.S. Sen. Chuck Schumer says a handful of powerful meatpacking companies are a major reason why.
Standing at a Tops supermarket in Walworth on Monday, Schumer unveiled new federal legislation aimed at breaking up dominant meatpacking corporations, boosting competition and lowering food costs for consumers across the Rochester-Finger Lakes region. The proposal, dubbed the Family Grocery and Farmer Relief Act, would also seek to strengthen opportunities for smaller farmers and meat producers throughout Upstate New York.
The announcement comes as grocery prices in the Finger Lakes have climbed dramatically over the past decade. According to data cited by Schumer, New York’s 24th Congressional District—which includes all of Wayne, Seneca, Yates, Livingston, Orleans, Wyoming and Genesee counties, along with portions of Ontario, Cayuga, Schuyler and Steuben counties—has seen average monthly grocery costs increase from roughly $710 to $1,080, a jump of more than 50%. Monroe County and parts of Ontario County have experienced similar increases.
Schumer argued that consolidation within the meat industry has contributed significantly to those rising costs. According to the senator, four companies—Tyson Foods, JBS, Cargill and National Beef—control 85% of the nation’s beef market, 67% of the pork market and 60% of the chicken market. He said that concentration limits competition, squeezes farmers and leaves consumers paying higher prices at the checkout line.
The legislation would require the largest meatpacking firms to choose between operating in the beef, pork or chicken sectors rather than maintaining dominant positions across multiple markets. It would also provide financial and technical assistance to farmers’ cooperatives and smaller businesses seeking to acquire, expand or operate meat processing facilities, a move Schumer said could help build stronger regional supply chains.
For Finger Lakes farmers, the proposal is designed to address what Schumer describes as a marketplace increasingly tilted toward large corporations. The senator said farmers currently receive only a small share of every food dollar spent by consumers, while corporate meat processors continue to consolidate power and influence over pricing.
Labor leaders also voiced support for the proposal. Frank DeRiso, president of United Food and Commercial Workers Local One, said increased competition could benefit workers, producers and consumers alike by reducing corporate control over the food system.
The legislation faces a long road through Congress, but Schumer framed the effort as part of a broader push to tackle affordability concerns that continue to dominate conversations across the Finger Lakes, where both families and farmers have struggled to keep pace with rising food costs.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to news@fingerlakes1.com.