Advertisement
Friday, November 13, 2026NewslettersAdvertiseWatch FL1
GET LOCALGo ad-freeHigh school sportsLocal eventsObituaries
News

Report: NYS Supreme Court constitutional cap creates dysfunction

Report: NYS Supreme Court constitutional cap creates dysfunction

A new report found New York’s constitutional cap on state Supreme Court judges is cumbersome.

It showed a relative lack of Supreme Court judges created a backlog of cases, forcing administrative judges to use a workaround to get more acting Supreme Court judges on the bench. But what begins as a temporary designation turns into a long-term promotion.

Rachael Fauss, senior policy analyst for the advocacy group Reinvent Albany, said one problem with the process is its lack of transparency.

“We don’t know if there is a review that takes place of the performance of these judges,” Fauss explained. “Are they given this job in perpetuity without having the appropriate level of accountability and review to make sure they’re doing the best job for the public that they can?”

She adds as imperfect as it is, the current process is a necessary fixture to keep caseloads at manageable levels.

Finger Lakes Partners (Billboard)

One way to resolve the problem is the Uncap Justice Act, a constitutional amendment to remove the Supreme Court justice cap. It passed the state Legislature for the first time in 2024 but failed to pass again this year. Once approved for a second time by the state Legislature, New York voters can determine its fate.

Another recommendation is having a reporting mechanism to make judicial promotions more transparent. Acting Supreme Court judges are supposed to only serve in the capacity for a year but the report revealed the acting judges are repromoted to the same position year after year. It also noted the courts control how opaque the process is.

Oded Oren, executive director of the nonprofit Scrutinize, which focuses on court transparency, said implementing these recommendations shouldn’t be difficult.

“I think it all turns on the willingness of the court system to become more transparent and more open to the public,” Oren contended. “I will just add that I think we are at a time where public trust in the courts, not only in New York, but across the country is at an all-time low.”

Though trust in the country’s highest court is at an all-time low, polls show trust in state courts is on the rebound. Oren feels a surefire way to keep the trend going is to make the internal judicial promotion process more transparent so people understand why certain decisions are made.

[call-to-aciton]



Want to go ad-free?

Become an FL1 member and say goodbye to ads! Plus, you’ll be supporting a company rooted in the Finger Lakes for nearly 30 years.

$4.99 / month

Get ad-free access

Renews monthly. Cancel anytime through your account. Already contributing via Google? Sign in with your Google account and unlock ad-free access. Embedded YouTube videos and other third-party media players may still contain ads.

Start your day with FingerLakes1

Get the stories that matter from across the Finger Lakes, delivered to your inbox.

Your email will be added to our newsletter mailing list, hosted on Substack. Privacy policy