A contentious debate over union recognition for Seneca Falls town employees once again took center stage at Tuesday’s town board meeting, with no resolution in sight. The dispute revolves around whether the zoning officer position should be included in the proposed bargaining unit.
The board and the Civil Service Employees Association (CSEA) union largely agree on which positions should be unionized. However, the zoning officer’s classification as a managerial role has led to an impasse. Supervisor Schmidter argued that the position’s management responsibilities—such as budget oversight and supervisory duties—make it inappropriate for union inclusion.
Town Council, union representatives, and residents clashed over the issue. A motion to voluntarily recognize the union with the zoning officer included was proposed by Councilwoman Kaitlyn Laskoski, but failed to gain majority support. It now leaves the decision to the New York Public Employee Relations Board, which will address the issue in January.
Union representatives accused the town board of deliberately delaying the process and engaging in anti-union behavior. One longtime employee who spoke at the meeting expressed frustration. “We organized our union to ensure our voices are heard, but management continues to target us for standing up for our rights,” he said.
CSEA Region 5 Executive Vice President Chantalise DeMarco criticized the town for wasting taxpayer money on prolonged legal disputes. “This is a waste of resources. We’re not going anywhere, and we urge the board to reconsider its stance,” she stated.
The dispute has sparked tensions within the community, with residents and employees showing strong support for union recognition. A representative for the judiciary union in the region, called for unity noting that the Town Board could still change course.
RELATED: Town Faces Union-Busting Allegations in Seneca Falls Amid Labor Organizing Effort
Councilwoman Dawn Dyson, who supported the motion to recognize the union fully, voiced concerns about the financial and social costs of continuing the fight. “This is costing taxpayers an unnecessary amount for an outcome that seems predetermined,” she said.
- Town Faces Union-Busting Allegations in Seneca Falls Amid Labor Organizing Effort
- Seneca Falls won’t decide on landfill permit or host agreement until at least January; special meeting scheduled
- Seneca Falls Town Board narrowly approves 2025 budget amid concerns
- Residents point to unknown in landfill odors as SF Town Board tables local permit again by 5-0 vote
The union issue has become a flashpoint in town politics, reflecting broader concerns about worker rights and transparency. With PERB set to review the matter on January 7, 2025, all eyes are on the town board to see whether a resolution can be reached.

