Governor Kathy Hochul signed the Clean Slate Act (S.7551A/A.1029C), marking a significant policy shift in New York’s approach to criminal justice. The law allows for the sealing of certain criminal records years after a sentence or incarceration, provided the individual remains crime-free. This legislation excludes individuals convicted of serious crimes such as sex offenses, murder, and domestic terrorism, and law enforcement, prosecutors, school officials, and courts will retain access to all criminal records.
The Clean Slate Act aims to enhance economic opportunities for New Yorkers who have served their sentences and remained offense-free for a specified period. Misdemeanor convictions will be sealed three years post-release, and eligible felonies after eight years, contingent on no subsequent crimes. Governor Hochul emphasized that this law balances public safety concerns with the need to boost economic opportunity, stating that the legislation will aid individuals in securing employment and contribute to addressing the state’s workforce shortage.
However, the Act has also generated significant opposition. Critics argue that the law prioritizes criminals over victims, particularly those convicted of serious offenses like vehicular homicide and domestic violence. Senator Helming criticized the law for offering a “clean slate” to criminals, neglecting the ongoing suffering of victims and their families. She voiced concerns about the state’s tendency to enact pro-criminal legislation, citing a lack of consideration for victims.
Assembly Minority Leader Will Barclay also expressed strong objections, characterizing the law as a misguided policy that undermines the state’s judicial processes. He argued that the law conceals serious crimes from background checks and ignores the input of judges, victims, and prosecutors, thereby prioritizing offenders over crime victims.
State Senator Tom O’Mara’s criticism echoed similar sentiments, labeling the law as another pro-criminal policy in a series of Democrat-led initiatives. He highlighted concerns about the increasing crime rates and lawlessness in New York, arguing that the Clean Slate Act further jeopardizes community safety and neglects the interests of law-abiding citizens and crime victims.
Despite these criticisms, New York becomes the 12th state to enact such legislation. Studies, including one by the Cato Institute, suggest that individuals with expunged records are less likely to commit crimes compared to the general population. The law is poised to address significant racial disparities in the criminal justice system and stimulate economic activity by unlocking the potential of individuals with criminal records. The Clean Slate Act goes into effect one year from its signing, with the New York State Office of Court Administration being given up to three years to implement necessary processes.
FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading all-digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Have a lead? Send it to [email protected].