Skip to content
Home » News » New York State » Bail law changes continue to be sticking point in NY budget talks: Extender approved buying lawmakers more time

Bail law changes continue to be sticking point in NY budget talks: Extender approved buying lawmakers more time

  • / Updated:
  • Staff Report 

New York’s ongoing budget negotiations, now overdue by 10 days, are primarily focused on potential amendments to the state’s bail law.


State Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie spoke with journalists on Monday, explaining that the discussions largely revolve around Governor Kathy Hochul’s proposal to simplify the process for judges to set cash bail in cases involving serious criminal offenses.

Heastie stressed the importance of carefully considering every aspect of the proposal, as it involves real-life situations and has a direct impact on people’s lives. The process entails coming up with a concept, examining its implications, and then assessing how it would work under real-life circumstances.


Governor Hochul has expressed her determination to include an amendment to the 2019 law in the budget agreement. This law, which significantly reduced the use of cash bail for most criminal charges in New York, has become a focal point in the state’s politics, particularly with the recent increase in crime rates coinciding with the COVID-19 pandemic.

Proponents of the current law argue that it helps prevent low-income defendants from being stuck in jail while awaiting trial. Conversely, critics claim that the law has made the state less secure.

Earlier in the day, legislators approved a temporary one-week extension of New York’s spending, ensuring that the state government continues to function and that 83,000 state workers receive their pay. However, the extension did not encompass the policy changes desired by Governor Hochul, even though she currently possesses the power and leverage to implement them during the budget negotiations. For the time being, lawmakers do not anticipate her doing so.